2012 Best and fairest votes
| 1st | Heath Scotland | 362 |
| 2nd | Eddie Betts | 353 |
| 3rd | Chris Judd | 334 |
| 4th | Brock McLean | 321 |
| 5th | Marc Murphy | 299 |
| 6th | Andrew Carrazzo | 287 |
| 7th | Kade Simpson | 229 |
| 8th | Bryce Gibbs | 228 |
| 9th | Mitch Robinson | 205 |
| 10th | Matthew Kreuzer | 163 |
Voting System
All five members of the Match Committee voted independently for a minimum of three, and a maximum of eight players.Players chosen received a maximum of 10 votes, meaning that the outstanding player each round could potentially be awarded 50 votes.
For Example: Player X received 8 votes from each of the 5 members of Match Committee, making his total 40 votes for the round (8 X 5 = 40).
