| Year | Goals Kicked | Player | Year | Goals Kicked | Player |
| 1897 | 15 | Wally O'Cock | 1915 | 46 | Herb Burleigh |
| 1898 | 8 | Tommy O'Day | 1916 | 44 | Vin Gardiner |
| 1899 | 8 | Harry Thompson | 1917 | 22 | Vin Gardiner |
| 1900 | 18 | Joe Sullivan | 1918 | 35 | Ern Cowley |
| 1901 | 14 | Joe Sullivan | 1919 | 36 | Charlie Fisher |
| 1902 | 11 | Fred Webber | 1920 | 48 | Horrie Clover |
| 1903 | 27 | Joe Sullivan | 1921 | 58 | Horrie Clover |
| 1904 | 26 | Mick Grace | 1922 | 56 | Horrie Clover |
| 1905 | 25 | Frank Caine | 1923 | 28 | Horrie Clover |
| 1906 | 50 | Mick Grace | 1924 | 27 | Alex Duncan |
| 1907 | 32 | Frank Caine | 1925 | 35 | Harvey Dunn |
| 1908 | 34 | Vin Gardiner | 1926 | 38 | Horrie Clover |
| 1909 | 36 | George Topping | 1927 | 33 | Harold Carter |
| 1910 | 42 | Vin Gardiner | 1928 | 41 | Horrie Clover |
| 1911 | 47 | Vin Gardiner | 1929 | 64 | Harry Vallence |
| 1912 | 47 | Vin Gardiner | 1930 | 56 | Les Allen |
| 1913 | 27 | Vin Gardiner | 1931 | 86 | Harry Vallence |
| 1914 | 27 | Bill Cook | 1932 | 97 | Harry Vallence |
Carlton's top goalkicker from 1897 to 1932