| Player | Era | Recruited From |
| Mark Stevens * | 1993 | Heyfield (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Mark Mabilia * | 1993 | Kilcunda-Bass (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Hugh Jack * | 1996 | Bairnsdale (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Callum White * | 1997 | Bairnsdale / Wonthaggi (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| David Pitt * | 1998 | Warragul (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Luke Bermingham * | 1998 | Police Boys / Traralgon (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Andrew Kiely * | 1998 | Yarram (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Joel Bradshaw * | 1999 | Sale (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Matthew N. Watson * | 1999 & 2000 - 2002 | Warragul (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Ben Bailey * | 1999 | Glengarry (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Joe Allen * | 2000 | Garfield |
| Dan O'Loughlin * | 2000 | Pakenham (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Ben Kilday * | 2002 | Warragul (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Sam Pleming * | 2004 - 2005 | Maffra (Rookie) |
| Callum Chambers | 2005 - 2006 | West Coast / Gippsland Power / Lucknow |
| Dylan McLaren | 2006 - 2007 | Brisbane / Gippsland Power / Sale |
| Craig Flint * | 2006 - 2007 | Churchill |
| Nick Heyne * | 2012 | St Kilda / Orbost-Snowy Rovers |
| Nick Graham | 2013 - 2018 | Traralgon-Tyers United |
| Dale Thomas | 2014 - 2019 | Collingwood / Drouin |
| Sam Docherty | 2014 - ? | Brisbane Lions / Phillip Island |
| Harry McKay | 2016 - ? | Warragul / St Paul's Anglican Grammar School |
| Jed Lamb | 2016 - 2018 | GWS Giants / Sydney Swans / Gippsland U18's / Yarram |
| Tomas Bugg * | 2019 | Melbourne / GWS Giants / Gippsland Power U18's / Caulfield Grammar / Gembrook-Cockatoo Junior FC / Beaconsfield FC |
| Fraser Phillips * | 2020 | Warragul FC |
NB * Didn't, or is yet to play senior football with Carlton.