|Doug Fraser||1910||Via Yarraville, Victoria|
|Bruce Campbell||1911||Also played at Fitzroy and Melbourne|
|William Morgan||1921||Also played at South Melbourne|
|Brighton Diggins||1938 - 1940||Premiership Captain / Sth Melbourne|
|Mike Fitzpatrick||1975 – 1983||Premiership Captain|
|Damian Hampson||1991 - 1992||Did not play a game for Carlton|
|Simon White||2010 - 2017||Picked up as a Rookie in the 2010 draft / Carine, WA|
|Josh Deluca||2019 -||Picked up in 2019 Mid-Season Rookie Draft / Sorrento Duncraig JFC (also played at Peel Thunder whilst at Fremantle Dockers)|
Vin Catoggio also had a stint at Subiaco in 1977.
Each of Diggins and Fitzpatrick were indeed recognised in the Subiaco Team of the Century announced in 2008.