Blueseum - Online historical archive of the Carlton Football Club
Match Report
Round 4 · 1910
49vs32

6.13·4.8

CARLTON won by 17
DateSaturday · 28 May 1910
VenuePrinces Park
AttendanceUnknown
Margin17 pts
By the Quarter

Quarter-by-Quarter

TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
Carlton
0.3
3
1.5
11
4.11
35
6.13
49
49
South Melbourne
0.5
5
1.6
12
2.7
19
4.8
32
32
The Match

Match Report

Umpire: 'Lardie' Tulloch

Goalkickers: A.McDonald 3, G.Topping 2, A.Lang 1.

Reports: G.Topping (Carlton - striking. Suspended for 35 matches). Dick Casey (SM - striking. Suspended for 16 matches).

Game Review

This game is perhaps most memorable for the suspension of Blue George Topping for a whopping 35 games for striking South’s Bert Streckfuss. While serving his suspension, George acted as a field umpire in three VFL games, as well as some others in the VFA. Dick Casey of South Melbourne was also found guilty of striking Jim Marchbank and suspended for 16 games.

At the end of this round Carlton were in 1st spot on the ladder with a percentage of 173.0.

Disgraceful Ruffianism
This football season has been the roughest yet, and violent incidents on and off the field are causing concern to football administration and even the Government. Perhaps the worst display occurred at the South Melbourne and Carlton match, when the game degenerated into a series of scrimmages, notwithstanding Carlton's win by 17 points. The worst incident occurred towards the end of the game when George Topping of Carlton felled Albet Streckfuss. People from the crowd surged over the fence and milled around and jostled around the felled player, while Andy McDonald picked up the ball and kicked Carlton's sixth goal. Topping has been disqualified for two seasons over the incident. - 100 Years of Australian Rules Football.

To read the Singleton Argus (NSW) report of this incident, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article76914810

16853.gif

Team

B:

Norman Clark

Doug Gillespie

Dick Harris

HB:

Bill Goddard

Percy Sheehan

Arthur Ford

C:

Tom Clancy

Rod McGregor

George Bruce

HF:

Jack Baquie

Jim Marchbank

Martin Gotz

F:

Alex Barningham

George Topping

Andy McDonald

Ruck:

Fred Elliott (cc)

Jack Wells

Alex Lang

Coach:

Fred Elliott

Changes

In: N.Clark
Out: L.Batty

By the Numbers

Player Statistics

Carlton

#PlayerKIHBDIMKGLBHGAIFMIUPBOTKRB1%FFFACPCMCLCGHOBR%P
-Alex LangAlex Lang----1------------------
-Andy McDonaldAndy McDonald----3------------------
-George ToppingGeorge Topping----2------------------
Team Total----6------------------
Team Average----2.0------------------

Last updated by Jamie Sanderson ·