| Number | Games Played | Player |
| 2 | John Nicholls | 328 |
| 11 | Bruce Doull | 329 |
| 21 | Craig Bradley | 375 |
| 25 | Alex Jesaulenko | 279 (Carlton and St Kilda) |
| 28 | Peter Jones | 249 |
| 42 | Robert Walls | 218 |
| 43 | Anthony Koutoufides | 278 |
| 44 | Justin Madden | 332 (Carlton and Essendon) |
NB In 2009, Simon Goodwin of the Crows beat Mark Maclure's guernsey record of 243 games in guernsey #36.