| Player | Era | Recruited from: |
| Bill Woodhouse | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Broken Hill, NSW / St Kilda VFA / Melb. Grammar |
| Jack Loughnan | 1912 | Hay, NSW |
| Ernie McAlpine | 1924, 1926 | Hume Weir, NSW |
| Gerald O'Halloran | 1925 | Sydney District, NSW |
| Hope Evans | 1925 | Albury, NSW |
| Les Witto | 1926 | Broken Hill West, NSW |
| Bill Donald | 1927 | Hume Weir, NSW |
| Frank Seymour | 1927 - 1928 | Mulwala |
| Les Gregory | 1944 - 1945 | Nth Adelaide / Albury, NSW / Richmond 2nd's |
| Jack Hardy | 1949 | Newtown Hill, NSW / Carlton / University Blacks / Essendon 2nd's |
| John Brown | 1950-1955 | NSW / Abbotsford Tech. |
| Ron O'Dwyer | 1956-1958 | Broken Hill North, NSW |
| Des Lyons | 1960 | Leeton, NSW |
| Tom Carroll | 1961 - 1963 | Ganmain, NSW |
| Jim Carroll | 1961 - 1962 | Ganmain, NSW |
| Mark Maclure | 1974 - 1986 | East Sydney, NSW |
| Rod Galt | 1975 - 1979 | Western Suburbs NSW / St Kilda / Beaumaris |
| Denis Lenaghan | 1981 - 1982 | Pennant Hills NSW / Sandhurst / Bendigo YCW |
| Rod Waddell | 1981 - 1982 | Collingwood Reserves / Lalor / Southern Districts, NSW |
| Greg Sharp | 1981 - 1983 | Western Suburbs NSW |
| David Honybun | 1984 | Coleambally, NSW / Uni. Blues / Mackay, QLD / Uni. Blacks / Scotch College / Coleambally, NSW |
| Gerard Butts | 1988 - 1989 | North Albury, NSW |
| Tim Powell | 1993 - 1994 | Richmond / Assumption College Kilmore / Berrigan, NSW |
| Peter Green | 1994 | Sydney / Barellan, NSW |
| Damian Lang | 1998 | Port Adelaide SANFL / Sydney / Leeton NSW |
| Adam Chatfield | 1998 - 2001 | NSW – ACT Rams / Pennant Hills NSW |
| Sam Rowe | 2012 - 2018 | Walla Walla, NSW, Nth Albury NSW, Murray Bushrangers, Sydney Rookie, Norwood, SA |
| Matthew Lodge * | 2012 | Byron Bay Magpies, NSW |
| Mark Whiley | 2015 - 2016 | Finley, NSW |
| Harrison Macreadie | 2017 - 2020 | Henty, NSW |
| Matt Kennedy | 2018 - ? | GWS Giants / Collingullie-Glenfield Park, NSW | Will Setterfield | 2019 - 2022 | GWS Giants / Dandenong Stingrays / Caulfield Grammar / Edithvale-Aspendale / Scots School NSW / Albury FC (NSW) |
| Michael Gibbons | 2019 - 2021 | Williamstown (VFL) / Murray Bushrangers (TAC) / Lavington (NSW) / Coolamon (NSW) | Zac Williams | 2021 - ? | GWS Giants / Narrandera FC (NSW) | Luke Parks | 2021 - 2022 | St Ives (NSW) / Sydney Swans Academy / Glenelg (SANFL) |
W. 'Bill' Newing. Bill Newing the 'little wonder' played for the Waratah club in Sydney 1877.