| Carlton | 2.1 | 13 | 3.5 | 23 | 5.9 | 39 | 9.11 | 65 | | Melbourne | 4.1 | 25 | 7.3 | 45 | 10.7 | 67 | 11.13 | 79 |
| Venue: M.C.G. | Date: Saturday April 12, 1958 |
| Result: Lose by 14 points | Umpire: | Crowd: 38,006 |
| Goalkickers: B.Crowe 4, L.Brereton 2, G.Donaldson 1, R.O'Dwyer 1, D.Zeunert 1. |
| Reports: | Injuries: |
Game Review
Team
| B: | 15 Bruce Comben (c) | 25 George Ferry | 2 John Nicholls |
| HB: | 19 Denis Zeunert | 3 Peter Webster | 10 John James |
| C: | 28 Graham Gilchrist | 12 Don Nicholls | 30 Jack Sullivan |
| HF: | 11 Laurie Kerr (vc) | 33 Ross Ousley | 17 Doug Beasy |
| F: | 5 Gerald Burke | 14 Bob Crowe | 7 Ron O'Dwyer |
| Ruck: | 13 Graham Donaldson | 16 Kevin Clarke | 6 Leo Brereton |
| Res: | 24 Vic Garra | 4 Brian Buckley | |
| Coach: | Jim Francis |
Emergencies were; Arch, White, McColl and Benetti.
1958 |
Round 2
