Carlton demolished St Kilda by 56 points at Princes Park

Round 15, 1955

Carlton 3.8 26 4.17 41 9.21 75 11.21 87
St Kilda 1.0 6 1.3 9 1.4 10 3.13 31
Venue: Princes Park Date: Saturday July 30, 1955
Result: Win by 56 points Umpire: V.Cardwell Crowd: 9,742
Goalkickers: N.O'Brien 6, G.Burke 3, D.Beasy 1, K.Bergin 1.
Reports: John Brown (Striking Ray Houston) - Not Guilty; George Ferry (Striking Bruce Phillips) - Not Guilty & (Striking Bruce McLennan) - 4 Matches;
Bill Milroy (Striking Brian Gilmour) - 4 Matches.
Injuries: Webster (jaw) replaced by Molony at half time. Beasy (shoulder) replaced by Munro in last quarter.

Game Review

The Blues made it four in a row with this 56-point pummelling of the bottom of the ladder Saints, but the game was far from memorable, with one newspaper accusing the Saints of 'committing every sin in the book.'

The victory was achieved at some cost, including the suspension of key Blues Bill Milroy and George Ferry. St Kilda's Bruce Phillips was reported twice for striking George, but exonerated on both counts. Brian Gilmour copped 4 weeks for striking Noel O'Brien. St Kilda coach Les Foote decided to try to make amends soon after the final siren, by taking his team as a group to the usual after-match get-together - only to find a notice attached to the door advising that the function had been cancelled.

Carlton remained in 7th spot, just one game ahead of Richmond in 8th.

"St.Kilda's display against Carlton proved it is the rightful holder of the 1955 'wooden spoon.' On Saturday's form St.Kilda would have difficulty in beating leading Association sides." (The Saints did win the 1955 spoon)

In a spiteful game Carlton should have won by more than the 56 points. The Blues won all over the ground and left their opponents "flat footed." The game was as good as over at half time with the inaccurate Blues having 21 shots to 4.

As mentioned above, the St.Kilda players were banned from attending the Carlton rooms for after game drinks.
To read the full story click here> http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article71670885

Carlton coach Perc Bentley

"I can't understand how St.Kilda hope to get anywhere by playing the type of football they played against us. The fundamental principle in football is to get the ball. I sent my side out to play football, which they did. They were told to give "Nobby" O'Brien the fullest opportunity to score. Once again our captain Ken Hands was the best man on the ground, and he did everything possible to give us a win. I thought Cardwell, the umpire, did a fair job in his first match."


B: 15 Bruce Comben 25 George Ferry 3 Peter Webster
HB: 19 Denis Zeunert 14 Vin English 16 John Brown
C: 23 John Chick 20 Leon Berner 11 Laurie Kerr
HF: 28 Graham Gilchrist 34 Bob Crowe 10 John James
F: 5 Gerald Burke 26 Noel O'Brien 17 Doug Beasy
Ruck: 2 Bill Milroy (vc) 1 Ken Hands (c) 36 Kevin Bergin
Res: 31 Brian Molony 22 Frank Munro
Coach: Percy Bentley


Hands, Chick, O'Brien, James, Comben, Bergin.


O'Brien 6.1, Burke 3.1, Beasy 1.4, Bergin 1.3, Gilchrist 0.3, James 0.2, Crowe 0.2, Milroy 0.2, Hands 0.1, Chick 0.1, rushed 1


O'Brien still heads the VFL goal kicking, his tally now is 65 goals, 4 ahead of Geelong's N. Rayson.


Round 14 | Round 16
Contributors to this page: Jarusa , Bombasheldon , blueycarlton , PatsFitztrick , molsey , kkk , WillowBlue , camelboy and admin .
Page last modified on Tuesday 16 of February, 2021 00:14:28 AEDT by Jarusa.

Google Search

Random Image

Charlotte Wilson 2019
2017 - Craig Bolton & Coaching Group.

Online Users

221 online users