Reserves Season 1942
Coach: TBD Harry Vallence appointed see July 31
Captain: TBD
Best & Fairest: No award
Position: 8th
Premier: St Kilda
.* Jack Stogdell appears in 1949 Chelsea team photo see Chelsea Football and Netball Club site.
Geelong, because of war time travel restrictions went into recession and did not compete in the Seniors or Reserves this year.
Due to man-power shortages, Collingwood, Hawthorn, and Richmond maintained a Senior team, but did not compete in the 1942 Reserves competition.
Due to wartime requirements South Melbourne's home ground the Lake Oval was unavailable, and South's seniors played home games at Princes Park. It seems that Carlton Reserves played their home games at McAlister Oval which is off Park Street, Parkville. The oval is still there, its a good drop kick north-west from Princes Park on the other other side of the Brunswick railway line, west of Sydney Road.
The Argus 16 May (p10) said Carlton seconds to play at Ryder Oval, Footscray at Yarraville, Melbourne and South Melbourne at the Albert Ground, Richmond at Old Scotch Ground, St.Kilda at Prahran, with Essendon, Fitzroy and North Melbourne to play on their own grounds.
Wartime requirements for rubber and leather, and the shortage of manpower, means that the manufacture of footballs will be in short supply.
May 16
Opening round
Carlton played South Melbourne at the Albert ground. (The old Warehouseman's ground (St.Kilda Road) from VFA days)
Carlton team;
Backs; Bignell, McIntyre, Atkinson
Half backs; Davies, Anderson, Eldridge or Bradley
Centres; Kinder, Power, Fitzgerald
Half forwards; Irvine, Boys, Butler
Forwards; Bennett, Morgan, Andrews
Followers; Stogdell, Stanfield
Rover; Price
Emergencies; Stanley, Clifford, Dakis, Brown, B. Green
Umpire; Leverett
Three quarter time; 10.8.68 - 15.14.104
Carlton lost; 10.10.70 - 22.20.152
Reserves Ladder; Carlton
The Football Record had Carlton in fifth place.
Played 1, Won 0, Lost 1, Drawn 0, For 70, Against 152, 46.05%, Points 0
May 23
Carlton played Essendon at McAlister Oval (Herald Friday said Ryder Oval)
(Ryder Oval is adjacent to McAlister Oval)
The oval is in Park Street Brunswick, just over the Upfield railway line.
Carlton team; (22 named)
From; Atkinson, Beer, Bignell, Bradbury, Bradley, Boys, Browne, Butler, Carney, Clifford, Collicoat, Dakis, Eldridge, Fitzgerald, Hale, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Power, Price, Standfield, Stogdell.
Backs; Bignell, Atkinson, Collicoat
Half backs; Bradley, Bradbury, Elderidge
Centre; Carney, Power, Fitzgerald
Half forwards; Irvine, Howell, Butler
Forwards; Brown, Boys, Beer
Followers; Stanfield, Stodgell
Rover; Price
Emergencies; Davis, Kinder, Hale, Clifford.
Carlton won by 55 points
Carl; 3.7, 6.12, 10.19, 13.24.112
Ess; 2.0, 5.1, 6.2, 9.3.57
May 30
Carlton played Fitzroy
.*Saturday's Age said "The new follower Stogdell, of Chelsea, is unable to obtain leave."
Carlton team
Backs; Sleith, Ryan, Grieve or Brown
Half backs; Boys, Baird, Andrew
Centres; Rivers, Collicoat, Fitzgerald
Half forwards; Irvine, Howell, Butler
Forwards; Stogdell*, Morgan, Beer
Followers; Hollingshead, Stanfield
Rover; Price
Emergencies; Clark, Power, Eldridge, Bradbury, Bradley, Dakis, Ross.
Carlton lost; 10.12.72 - 11.15.81
June 06
Carlton played Richmond
Carlton team; (28 named)
From; Bignall, Ryan, Grieve Stodgell, Morgan, Sleith, Atkinson, Harbour, Clark, Collicoat, F. White, Baird, Howell, Boys, Stanfield, Ross, Irvine, Hollingshead, Brown, Beer, Dakis, Eldridge, Green, Power, Bradbury, Kinder, Fitzgerald, Neville.
Carlton lost; 12.12.84 - 15.16.106
Reserves Ladder; Carlton 7th.
Played 4, Won 1, Lost 3, Drawn 0, For 338, Against 396, 85.3%, Points 4
June 13
Carlton played North Melbourne
Carlton team; (24 named)
From; Andrew, Bignell, Brown, Beer, Boys, Clarke, Collicoat, Dakis, Fitzgerald, B. Green, Hollingshead, Harbour, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Morgan, Neville, Power, Ross, Ryan, Standfield, Hodgell, White, Sleith.
Carlton won; 13.13.91 - 4.10.34
June 20
Carlton played Footscray at Princes Park
(Carlton were at the Western Oval & South Melb. were playing at Punt Road.)
Carlton team; (23 named)
From; Andrews, Bignell, Brown, Beer, Bradbury, Boys, Collicoat, Clark, Dakis, Fitzgerald, Green, Harbour, Hollingshead, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Neville, Power, Ross, Sleith, Hogells, Stanfield, White.
Umpire; Glasson
Carlton lost; 16.12.108 - 17.11.113
Reserves Ladder; Carlton 6th.
Played 6, Won 2, Lost 4, Drawn 0, For, Against , %, Points 8
June 27
As yet unable to find a Carlton reserves' game.
Perhaps Carlton had the bye.
Four matches known this weekend.
Melbourne-South Melbourne
Essendon-St.Kilda
Fitzroy-Richmond
Footscray-North Melbourne
July 04
Carlton played Melbourne at McAlister Oval
Carlton team; (21 named)
Andrew, Beer, Bradbury, Boys, Collicoat, Dakes/Dakis, Fitzgerald, Green, Harbour, Hollingshead, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Neville, Power, Ross, Sleith, Stogdell, Mann, Morgan, White
Umpire; Morgan
Carlton lost by 2 points
Carl; 1.3 4.6 4.7 7.7.49
Melb; 3.4 3.5 5.7 7.9.51
July 11
Carlton played St.Kilda
Carlton lost by 98 points
Carl; 2.4 2.6 5.12 7.14.56
St.K; 2.4 8.9 14.12 22.22.154
Carlton eighth of nine teams.
Essendon 28, Footscray 28, Richmond 28, St.Kilda 24, Fitzroy 24, South Melbourne 16, Melbourne 16, Carlton 12, North Melbourne 4.
July 16
Permits granted to Carlton, L. Bragge (Preston), R. B. Blackwood (Morwell) (Age p4)
July 18
Carlton played North Melbourne at Princes Park
Umpire; Leverett
Carlton lost by 17 points
Carl; 1.5 5.7 6.14 7.19.61
N.M; 1.3 4.7 9.9 11.12.78
July 25
Carlton played Footscray at Newport
Umpire; Heywood
Carlton lost by 95 points
Carl; 0.3 1.8 2.11 6.15.51
Foots; 4.6 12.7 20.10 22.14.146
July 31 Friday
Carlton has signed up A. H. Taylor, a half forward from Williamstown. He trained impressively last night.
T. D. Maher (East Coburg Colts)
Harry Vallence has been appointed coach of the second eighteen.
Bennett the follower is still unavailable.
(Age p4 & Age Thursday p4)
August 01
Carlton played South Melbourne at Princes Park
Former Blue George Collard played for Bloods and was one of their better players
Carlton lost by 46 points
Carl; 1.2 4.8 4.12 5.20.50
SM; 3.10 5.15 10.21 12.24.96
Goals; Harry Vallence 1, rest unknown
Carlton eighth
Ladder; Richmond 40, St.Kilda 36, Footscray 36, Essendon 32, Fitzroy 32, Melbourne 24, South Melbourne 20, Carlton 12, North Melbourne 8
August 08
Carlton played Essendon
Carlton lost 139 points
Carlton 6.2.38 - Essendon 24.33.177
August 15
Carlton played Fitzroy
Carlton lost by 67 points
Carlton 8.12.60 - Fitzroy 18.19.127
August 22
Final round of the season.
Carlton played Richmond
Carlton lost by 144 points.
Carlton 6.3.39 - Richmond 25.23.183
Coach: TBD Harry Vallence appointed see July 31
Captain: TBD
Best & Fairest: No award
Position: 8th
Premier: St Kilda
Final List
Old
Anderson, Bailey, Baird, Bennett, Bignall, Brown, Butler, Carney, Chitty, Cooper, Francis, Gill, Green, McIntyre, McInnes, Mooring, Price, Sanger, Savage, Schmidt, Sleith, Wrout.New
R. Atkinson (Coburg), W. Atkinson (RAAF), L. Collins (Coburg), Gniel (Geelong), Howell (Chelsea), Irvine (Coburg), Knight (Geelong), Morgan (Northcote), Standfield (Brunswick), Frank White (Werribee South)To be added when available
Connellan (West Melbourne), Bert Deacon (Preston), Mann (Preston)Supplementary
Ted Andrews (rover, Carlton seconds), Jack Bradbury (follower) , Ron Boys (17 yo 6ft local schoolboy champion), W. Brown (Coburg), Jim Clark (Elmore), Collicoat, Cripps, H. Davies, Dawson, Eldridge, C. Fitzgerald, C. Green, Lummus, Marriott, Powell, Power, Stanley, Jack Stogdell *(Chelsea), S. Wilson.D. D. McHugh (Wedderburn),.* Jack Stogdell appears in 1949 Chelsea team photo see Chelsea Football and Netball Club site.
World War 2 Problems
The Reserves this year is an eight team competition consisting of Carlton, Essendon, Fitzroy, Footscray, Melbourne, Richmond, South Melbourne, and North Melbourne.Geelong, because of war time travel restrictions went into recession and did not compete in the Seniors or Reserves this year.
Due to man-power shortages, Collingwood, Hawthorn, and Richmond maintained a Senior team, but did not compete in the 1942 Reserves competition.
Due to wartime requirements South Melbourne's home ground the Lake Oval was unavailable, and South's seniors played home games at Princes Park. It seems that Carlton Reserves played their home games at McAlister Oval which is off Park Street, Parkville. The oval is still there, its a good drop kick north-west from Princes Park on the other other side of the Brunswick railway line, west of Sydney Road.
The Argus 16 May (p10) said Carlton seconds to play at Ryder Oval, Footscray at Yarraville, Melbourne and South Melbourne at the Albert Ground, Richmond at Old Scotch Ground, St.Kilda at Prahran, with Essendon, Fitzroy and North Melbourne to play on their own grounds.
Wartime requirements for rubber and leather, and the shortage of manpower, means that the manufacture of footballs will be in short supply.
May 16
Opening round
Carlton played South Melbourne at the Albert ground. (The old Warehouseman's ground (St.Kilda Road) from VFA days)
Carlton team;
Backs; Bignell, McIntyre, Atkinson
Half backs; Davies, Anderson, Eldridge or Bradley
Centres; Kinder, Power, Fitzgerald
Half forwards; Irvine, Boys, Butler
Forwards; Bennett, Morgan, Andrews
Followers; Stogdell, Stanfield
Rover; Price
Emergencies; Stanley, Clifford, Dakis, Brown, B. Green
Umpire; Leverett
Three quarter time; 10.8.68 - 15.14.104
Carlton lost; 10.10.70 - 22.20.152
Reserves Ladder; Carlton
The Football Record had Carlton in fifth place.
Played 1, Won 0, Lost 1, Drawn 0, For 70, Against 152, 46.05%, Points 0
May 23
Carlton played Essendon at McAlister Oval (Herald Friday said Ryder Oval)
(Ryder Oval is adjacent to McAlister Oval)
The oval is in Park Street Brunswick, just over the Upfield railway line.
Carlton team; (22 named)
From; Atkinson, Beer, Bignell, Bradbury, Bradley, Boys, Browne, Butler, Carney, Clifford, Collicoat, Dakis, Eldridge, Fitzgerald, Hale, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Power, Price, Standfield, Stogdell.
Backs; Bignell, Atkinson, Collicoat
Half backs; Bradley, Bradbury, Elderidge
Centre; Carney, Power, Fitzgerald
Half forwards; Irvine, Howell, Butler
Forwards; Brown, Boys, Beer
Followers; Stanfield, Stodgell
Rover; Price
Emergencies; Davis, Kinder, Hale, Clifford.
Carlton won by 55 points
Carl; 3.7, 6.12, 10.19, 13.24.112
Ess; 2.0, 5.1, 6.2, 9.3.57
May 30
Carlton played Fitzroy
.*Saturday's Age said "The new follower Stogdell, of Chelsea, is unable to obtain leave."
Carlton team
Backs; Sleith, Ryan, Grieve or Brown
Half backs; Boys, Baird, Andrew
Centres; Rivers, Collicoat, Fitzgerald
Half forwards; Irvine, Howell, Butler
Forwards; Stogdell*, Morgan, Beer
Followers; Hollingshead, Stanfield
Rover; Price
Emergencies; Clark, Power, Eldridge, Bradbury, Bradley, Dakis, Ross.
Carlton lost; 10.12.72 - 11.15.81
June 06
Carlton played Richmond
Carlton team; (28 named)
From; Bignall, Ryan, Grieve Stodgell, Morgan, Sleith, Atkinson, Harbour, Clark, Collicoat, F. White, Baird, Howell, Boys, Stanfield, Ross, Irvine, Hollingshead, Brown, Beer, Dakis, Eldridge, Green, Power, Bradbury, Kinder, Fitzgerald, Neville.
Carlton lost; 12.12.84 - 15.16.106
Reserves Ladder; Carlton 7th.
Played 4, Won 1, Lost 3, Drawn 0, For 338, Against 396, 85.3%, Points 4
June 13
Carlton played North Melbourne
Carlton team; (24 named)
From; Andrew, Bignell, Brown, Beer, Boys, Clarke, Collicoat, Dakis, Fitzgerald, B. Green, Hollingshead, Harbour, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Morgan, Neville, Power, Ross, Ryan, Standfield, Hodgell, White, Sleith.
Carlton won; 13.13.91 - 4.10.34
June 20
Carlton played Footscray at Princes Park
(Carlton were at the Western Oval & South Melb. were playing at Punt Road.)
Carlton team; (23 named)
From; Andrews, Bignell, Brown, Beer, Bradbury, Boys, Collicoat, Clark, Dakis, Fitzgerald, Green, Harbour, Hollingshead, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Neville, Power, Ross, Sleith, Hogells, Stanfield, White.
Umpire; Glasson
Carlton lost; 16.12.108 - 17.11.113
Reserves Ladder; Carlton 6th.
Played 6, Won 2, Lost 4, Drawn 0, For, Against , %, Points 8
June 27
As yet unable to find a Carlton reserves' game.
Perhaps Carlton had the bye.
Four matches known this weekend.
Melbourne-South Melbourne
Essendon-St.Kilda
Fitzroy-Richmond
Footscray-North Melbourne
July 04
Carlton played Melbourne at McAlister Oval
Carlton team; (21 named)
Andrew, Beer, Bradbury, Boys, Collicoat, Dakes/Dakis, Fitzgerald, Green, Harbour, Hollingshead, Howell, Irvine, Kinder, Neville, Power, Ross, Sleith, Stogdell, Mann, Morgan, White
Umpire; Morgan
Carlton lost by 2 points
Carl; 1.3 4.6 4.7 7.7.49
Melb; 3.4 3.5 5.7 7.9.51
July 11
Carlton played St.Kilda
Carlton lost by 98 points
Carl; 2.4 2.6 5.12 7.14.56
St.K; 2.4 8.9 14.12 22.22.154
Carlton eighth of nine teams.
Essendon 28, Footscray 28, Richmond 28, St.Kilda 24, Fitzroy 24, South Melbourne 16, Melbourne 16, Carlton 12, North Melbourne 4.
July 16
Permits granted to Carlton, L. Bragge (Preston), R. B. Blackwood (Morwell) (Age p4)
July 18
Carlton played North Melbourne at Princes Park
Umpire; Leverett
Carlton lost by 17 points
Carl; 1.5 5.7 6.14 7.19.61
N.M; 1.3 4.7 9.9 11.12.78
July 25
Carlton played Footscray at Newport
Umpire; Heywood
Carlton lost by 95 points
Carl; 0.3 1.8 2.11 6.15.51
Foots; 4.6 12.7 20.10 22.14.146
July 31 Friday
Carlton has signed up A. H. Taylor, a half forward from Williamstown. He trained impressively last night.
T. D. Maher (East Coburg Colts)
Harry Vallence has been appointed coach of the second eighteen.
Bennett the follower is still unavailable.
(Age p4 & Age Thursday p4)
August 01
Carlton played South Melbourne at Princes Park
Former Blue George Collard played for Bloods and was one of their better players
Carlton lost by 46 points
Carl; 1.2 4.8 4.12 5.20.50
SM; 3.10 5.15 10.21 12.24.96
Goals; Harry Vallence 1, rest unknown
Carlton eighth
Ladder; Richmond 40, St.Kilda 36, Footscray 36, Essendon 32, Fitzroy 32, Melbourne 24, South Melbourne 20, Carlton 12, North Melbourne 8
August 08
Carlton played Essendon
Carlton lost 139 points
Carlton 6.2.38 - Essendon 24.33.177
August 15
Carlton played Fitzroy
Carlton lost by 67 points
Carlton 8.12.60 - Fitzroy 18.19.127
August 22
Final round of the season.
Carlton played Richmond
Carlton lost by 144 points.
Carlton 6.3.39 - Richmond 25.23.183