Coach: Ken Aitken
Captain: TBD
Best & Fairest: Ian Hughes
Position: 4th
Premier: Richmond
This was the last season the Under 19 matches played as Curtain Raisers to seniors in First Round Matches.
(VFL Year Book 1988)Round 1: 12th April 1958.
Carlton 8.8.56
Melbourne 1.8.14
Result: Won by 42 points.
Goalkickers: Kiely 3, Cormack 3, Highes 1, Jordan 1.
Best: Hughes, McGhee, John Collis, Rowan, John Williams, Zarucky.
Round 2: 19th April 1958.
Carlton 5.10.40
North Melbourne 6.3.39
Result: Won by 1 point.
Goalkickers: Hughes 2, Cormack 1, Rowan 1, Bill Arthur 1.
Best: John Williams, Zarucky, Hughes, Dinley, Curtis Clarke, John Collis, Rowan.
Round 3: 26th April 1958.
Carlton 10.7.67
Geelong 8.8.56
Result: Won by 11 points.
Goalkickers: Jordan 2, Kiely 2, Rowan 2, Hughes 2, Curtis Clarke 1, Cormack 1.
Best: John Deftereos, Mal Heatley, John Williams, John Collis, Kiely, Zarucky.
Round 4: 3rd May 1958.
Carlton 3.7.25
St Kilda 4.6.30
Result: Lost by 5 points.
Goalkickers: Rowan 1, Keily 1, Watson 1.
Best: Mal Heatley, John Deftereos, John Williams, Zarucky, Garry Job, Dinlay, Watson.
Round 5: 10th May 1958.
Carlton 4.11.35
Collingwood 4.10.34
Result: Won by 1 point.
Goalkickers: Watson 2, Graham Eddy 1, Keily 1.
Best: Keily, John Deftereos, Graham Eddy, Mal Heatley, Watson, Garry Job, Muir.
Round 6: 17th May 1958.
Carlton 6.5.41
Fitzroy 4.6.30
Result: Won by 11 points.
Goalkickers: Hughes 2, Graham Eddy 1, Kiely 1, McGee 1, Jordon 1.
Best: Hughes, John Deftereos, John Williams, Kiely, John Collis, Garry Job.
Round 7: 24th May 1958.
Carlton 6.8.44
South Melbourne 7.8.50
Result: Lost by 6 points.
Goalkickers: Hughes 2, Cormack 2, Watson 1, Mal Heatley 1.
Best: Garry Job, Hughes, Mal Heatley, Kiely, Cormack, John Williams.
Round 8: 31st May 1958.
Carlton 15.10.100
Hawthorn 13.9.87
Result: Won by 13 points.
Goalkickers: Watson 5, Hughes 4, Graham Eddy 2, John Williams 2, Kiely 1, Cormack 1.
Best: Watson, Hughes, Dinley, Graham Eddy, John Williams, John Collis, Higgins.
Round 9: 7th June 1958.
Carlton 8.3.51
Essendon 5.8.38
Result: Won by 13 points.
Goalkickers: Watson 2, John Williams 2, Hughes 2, Graham Eddy 2.
Best: Mal Heatley, Hughes, Watson, Dennison, Graham Eddy, Garry Job.
Round 10: 14th June 1958.
Carlton 3.10.28
Richmond 9.6.60
Result: Lost by 32 points.
Goalkickers: Graham Eddy 1, Watson 1, Hughes 1.
Best: Bill Arthur, Hughes, John Williams, Mal Heatley, Graham Eddy.
Round 11: 21st June 1958.
Carlton 8.8.56
Footscray 9.8.62
Result: Lost by 6 points.
Goalkickers: Nash 2, John Williams 2, Watson 1, Bill Arthur 1, Graham Eddy 1, Kiely 1.
Best: Garry Job, Bill Arthur, Mal Heatley, Sewell, John Deftereos, John Collis.
Round 12: 28th June 1958.
Carlton 6.17.53
Melbourne 4.2.26
Result: Won by 27 points.
Goalkickers:
Best:
Leading Goalkickers: Hughes 17 goals (equal 3rd overall).
Round 13: 19th July 1958.
Carlton 9.6.60
North Melbourne 8.13.61
Result: Lost by 1 point.
Goalkickers: Nash 3, John Williams 3, Hughes 2, Graham Eddy 1.
Best: John Williams, Nash, Mal Heatley, John Collis, Graham Eddy.
Round 14: 26th July 1958.
Carlton 9.11.65
Geelong 9.4.58
Result: Won by 7 points.
Goalkickers: Nash 3, Wes Lofts 2, John Williams 2, Cody 1, Didier 1.
Best: Curtis Clarke, Mal Heatley, Wes Lofts, Muir, Cody, Rigly.
Round 15: 2nd August 1958.
Carlton 8.7.55
St Kilda 7.5.47
Result: Won by 8 points.
Goalkickers: Wes Lofts 4, Kiley 2, John Williams 1, Hughes 1.
Best: Wes Lofts, John Deftereos, John Collis, Graham Eddy, Len Nigro, Kiely.
Round 16: 9th August 1958.
Carlton 7.10.52
Collingwood 3.2.20
Result: Won by 32 points.
Goalkickers: Hughes 2, Nash 2, Graham Eddy 1, John Williams 1, Wes Lofts 1.
Best: Wes Lofts, John Deftereos, John Collis, Graham Eddy, Hughes, Garry Job.
1958 U/19's - End of Home & Away Season Ladder
| Pos | Team | Wins | Draws | Losses | Points | For | Against | % |
| 1 | Richmond | 13 | 0 | 3 | 52 | 1057 | 768 | 137.6 |
| 2 | Essendon | 13 | 0 | 3 | 52 | 894 | 668 | 133.8 |
| 3 | St Kilda | 12 | 0 | 4 | 48 | 762 | 517 | 147.3 |
| 4 | Carlton | 11 | 0 | 5 | 44 | 828 | 712 | 116.2 |
| 5 | South Melbourne | 10 | 0 | 6 | 40 | 874 | 738 | 118.4 |
| 6 | Footscray | 10 | 0 | 6 | 40 | 833 | 843 | 98.8 |
| 7 | Collingwood | 8 | 0 | 8 | 32 | 826 | 738 | 111.9 |
| 8 | Geelong | 6 | 0 | 10 | 24 | 756 | 892 | 84.7 |
| 9 | North Melbourne | 5 | 0 | 11 | 20 | 798 | 866 | 92.1 |
| 10 | Melbourne | 5 | 0 | 11 | 20 | 705 | 848 | 83.1 |
| 11 | Fitzroy | 2 | 0 | 14 | 8 | 672 | 1063 | 63.2 |
| 12 | Hawthorn | 1 | 0 | 15 | 4 | 705 | 1057 | 66.6 |
Note: The senior and reserves played an 18-game season whilst the U/19's played a 16-game season.
1958 U/19's Finals Series
1st Semi-Final - 16th August 1958.
St Kilda 12.9.81
Carlton 6.7.43
Result: Won by 38 points.
Goalkickers: Hughes 2, Nash 1, Wes Lofts 1, Kiely 1, Graham Eddy 1.
Best: Dennison, Curtis Clarke, Muir, Job, John Collis, Lamtzes, Hughes.
2nd Semi-Final - Richmond 10.11.71 d Essendon 6.4.40
Preliminary Final - Essendon 6.6.42 d St Kilda 5.7.37
Grand Final - Richmond 12.14.86 d Essendon 7.9.51