Sectional Round 1, Carlton lost to South Melbourne by 17 points at the Lakeside Oval.

Round 15, 1907

Carlton 3.7 25 3.10 28 3.13 31 4.16 40
South Melbourne 0.0 0 3.4 22 3.7 25 8.9 57
Venue: Lakeside Oval Date: Saturday August 17, 1907
Result: Loss by 17 points Umpire: J.Smith (ex St.Kilda captain) Crowd: 20,000
Goalkickers: A.Lang 2, D.Harris 1, J.Marchbank 1.
Reports: F.Elliott (guilty, suspended for remainder of season), J.Marchbank (guilty, suspended to June 1908), M.Gotz (not sustained). Injuries: J.Marchbank (fractured nose)

Game Review

This hard, sometimes vicious match against South Melbourne at the Lakeside Oval had huge ramifications for two of Carlton’s stars. Jim Marchbank and Fred Elliott had been key players all year for Carlton, but their dreams of a second successive Premiership with the Blues were dashed after both were suspended for striking.

Carlton began the game in grand style, kicking with the wind to post 3.7 and keeping the Bloods scoreless in the first quarter. Soon after the resumption of play however, skirmishes broke out among the ruck divisions of both sides and ill-tempered incidents marred the rest of the match. Yet again, Carlton’s poor shooting for goal from set shots and general play cost the side dearly. In the last three quarters, the Blues kicked 1.9 to finish with 4.16, while South added 8.9 and deserved to win by 17 points.

The real sensations came well after the match. At the time, foul play was becoming more prevalent and the VFL had pledged to act, so when complaints about the actions of both sides poured in, the authorities decided to make a statement about their intentions to clean up the game.

Carlton actually began proceedings by reporting South’s Bert Franks for striking several Blues players. South retaliated by accusing Marchbank, ‘Pompey’ Elliott and Martin Gotz of similar offences. The charge against Gotz was quickly dismissed, but the other two were found guilty and heavily penalised. Despite acknowledging that Marchbank’s record was ’irreproachable as a man and a footballer’ the tribunal suspended him for seven matches, while Elliott was outed for four games. This harsh treatment was compounded by both players missing out on a place in Carlton’s 1907 Premiership team. Perhaps the only small consolation was that Franks, too, was found guilty, and received a seven-match penalty.
The tribunal decision was made at 4.45am, which in 1907 was the longest football committee investigation on record.

At the end of this round Carlton were in 1st spot on the ladder with a percentage of 153.8.

Free Kicks

Third Quarter; Carlton 4, South 8


South Melbourne's W. Ghent was given a life suspension. (Border Morning Mail Albury 26 August p4)


B: Norman Clark (vc) Doug Gillespie Dick Harris
HB: Billy Payne Fred Jinks Martin Gotz
C: Ted Kennedy Rod McGregor George Bruce
HF: Frank Caine Jim Marchbank Alex Lang
F: Harvey Kelly George Topping Vin Gardiner
Ruck: George S Johnson Charlie Hammond Fred Elliott (acting capt.)
Coach: Jack Worrall


In: V.Gardiner
Out: L.Beck

Round 14 | Round 16
Contributors to this page: blueycarlton , Bombasheldon , PatsFitztrick , camelboy , molsey , kkk , WillowBlue , steve and admin .
Page last modified on Saturday 11 of September, 2021 14:19:19 AEST by blueycarlton.

Google Search

Random Image

2019 - Matthew Cottrell kicking at training.

Online Users

104 online users