| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Charlie Hay | 1910 | Mt Gambier, SA |
| Jack Bavin | 1940 | Narracorte / Mount Gambier, SA |
| Andrew McKay | 1993 - 2003 | Glenelg / Lucindale, SA |
| Lindsay Smith | 2002 | Nth Melb. / Glenelg / Bordertown, SA |
| Barnaby French | 2003 - 2006 | Port Power / Sturt / Ironbark (Hills Football League), SA |
| Eddie Betts | 2005 - 2023 & 2020 - 2021 | Mines Rovers FC WA / Mallee Park, SA / Templestowe (EFL) VIC / Calder Cannons |
| Sam Jacobs | 2007 - 2010 | Woodville-West Torrens / Ardrossan, SA |
| Darren Pfeiffer | 2008 - 2009 | Norwood / Birdwood, SA |
| Cameron Giles * | 2014 - 2015 | Woodville-West Torrens / Originally from Prince Alfred College / Blythe Snowtown, SA |
| Kym LeBois * | 2017 - 2019 | Nth Adelaide / Originally from Koonibba, SA |
| George Hewett | 2022 - ? | Sydney Swans / North Adelaide (SANFL) / Prince Alfred College / Port Broughton, SA. |
| Sam Durdin | 2022 - ? | Glenelg (SANFL) / North Melbourne / West Adelaide (SANFL) / East Murray, SA. |
NB * Denotes player did not, or is yet to play a game at senior level with Carlton.