The Fothergill–Round Medal is a Victorian Football League (VFL) award that is presented to the most promising young talent in the VFL competition. Named after Des Fothergill and Barry Round, the only two players who have won both the J. J. Liston Trophy and the Brownlow Medal, the medal has been awarded annually since 1989. It was renamed the Fothergill-Round-Mitchell in 2018 to also recognise Sam Mitchell, the third player to achieve the feat.
Note: The winners of the above award either had played or were to play with Carlton Reserves or the Northern Blues / Northern Bullants.
| Year | Name | Club |
| 1990 | Matheu Quirk | Oakleigh |
| 1991 | Ron De Iulio | Box Hill |
| 1992 | Julian Shanks | Williamstown |
| 1995 | Mark Porter | Coburg |
| 1999 | Mark Passador | Springvale |
| 2001 | Kristian De Pasquale | Coburg |
| 2011 | Ahmed Saad | Northern Bullants |
| 2013 | Kane Lambert | Northern Blues |
| 2014 | Nic Newman | Frankston |
Note: The winners of the above award either had played or were to play with Carlton Reserves or the Northern Blues / Northern Bullants.