| Game | Charge | Victim | Club | Penalty |
| Round 12, 1937 | Charging and Elbowing | Sandy Patterson | South Melbourne | Not Guilty |
| Round 18, 1940 | Striking | Bill Crosling | Footscray | Not Guilty |
| Round 6, 1941 | Elbowing | Alby Pannam | Collingwood | Guilty – 2 weeks |
| Round 13, 1942 | Unduly Rough Play | N/A | South Melbourne | Not Guilty |
| Round 11, 1944 | Assault | Bill McTaggart | Footscray | Not Guilty |
| Grand Final, 1945 | Elbowing | Billy Williams | South Melbourne | Guilty – 8 weeks |
| Round 13, 1946 | Striking | Fred Fanning | Melbourne | Guilty – 4 weeks |
In total, Chitty was suspended for a total of 14 weeks, after 7 charges were laid against him in the period 1937 to 1946.