| Player | Era | Recruited From |
| Mark Potter * | 1994 | Kyneton (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Stephen Sexton * | 1995 | Sandhurst (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Steven Reaper * | 1996 | Kyneton (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Michael Braun * | 1996 | Echuca United (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Kieran O'Shannessy * | 1997 | Walpeup-Underbool (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Paul McMahon * | 1997 | Lockington-Bamawm (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Peter Taylor * | 1997 | Echuca United (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Kieran Prowse * | 1997 | Sandhurst (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Cameron Cramp * | 1998 | Robinvale (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Ashley Fleming * | 1998 | Kyneton (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Damien Lock | 1998 - 1999 | Eaglehawk |
| Craig Parsons * | 1999 | Finley (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Heath Culpitt | 1999 - 2001 | Castlemaine |
| Brad Carroll * | 2000 | Tyntynder (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Brad Easton * | 2001 | South Mildura (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Jordan Doering | 2001 - 2002 | Sandhurst |
| Kristan Height * | 2002 | Echuca (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Andrew Briggs * | 1995 | Echuca (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Wayne Burchell * | 2002 | Castlemaine / Bendigo Pioneers / Maldon (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Simon Rosa * | 2002 | Donvale / Bendigo Pioneers / Brim (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Luke Livingston | 2002 - 2006 | Kerang |
| Callan Beasy | 2002 - 2004 | Swan Hill |
| Andrew Walker | 2004 - 2016 | Echuca |
| Ross Young | 2007 | Northern Bullants VFL / Uni.Blues / Bendigo Pioneers U/18's / Donald |
| Andrew Collins | 2011 - 2013 | Richmond / Bendigo Pioneers U/18's / Sandhurst / Sandhurst Marist Dockers |
| Sam Kerridge | 2016 - 2018 | Adelaide Crows / Bendigo Pioneers U/18's / Mildura |
| Paddy Dow | 2018 - 2023 | Geelong Grammar / Swan Hill |
| Lochie O'Brien | 2018 - 2023 | Geelong Grammar / South Mildura |
| Angus Schumacher | 2018 - 19 | Strathfieldsaye |
| Brodie Kemp | 2020 - ? | Echuca |
NB * Didn't, or is yet to play senior football with Carlton.
At the end of the 2013 season the Bendigo Pioneers Football Club named it best team of 21 years, the team included three players (Andrew Walker, Luke Livingston and Damien Lock who had played senior football with Carlton and another three players Steven Reaper, Simon Rosa and Michael Braun) who had a run with the Carlton reserves team (the latter player was to become a premiership player with the West Coast Eagles). The team was compiled with the help of former and present Bendigo Pioneer coaches that included two former Carlton players Brian Walsh and Tony Southcombe.