Carlton's Super Goals by Players 2004-2016
| No. | Player | Super Goals | |
| 42 | Zach Tuohy | 4 | 22 | Callum Chambers | 3 | 25 | Brendan Fevola | 3 | 3 | Marc Murphy | 3 | 3 | Digby Morrell | 2 | 24 | Nick Stevens | 2 | 28 | Tom Bell | 1 | 19 | Eddie Betts | 1 | 44 | Andrew Carrazzo | 1 | 28 | Cameron Cloke | 1 | 35 | Ed Curnow* | 1 | 33 | Andrejs Everitt | 1 | 14 | Brad Fisher | 1 | 4 | Bryce Gibbs | 1 | 16 | Shaun Grigg | 1 | 38 | Ryan Jackson | 1 | 8 | Matthew Kreuzer | 1 | 7/14 | Brock McLean | 1 | 2 | Troy Menzel | 1 | 28 | Ian Prendergast | 1 | 10 | Matthew Watson | 1 | 34 | Simon Wiggins | 1 | 36 | Cameron Wood | 1 |
-* Current Player
Carlton's Super Goals by Games 2004-2016
| Date | Against | Game | Quarter | Player |
| 22/2/04 | Sydney | 1st Round | 2nd | Digby Morrell | 28/2/04 | Geelong | Quarter Final | 1st | Digby Morrell | 20/2/05 | Essendon | 1st Round | 2nd | Callum Chambers | 20/2/05 | Essendon | 1st Round | 3rd | Callum Chambers | 27/2/05 | Melbourne | Quarter Final | 4th | Callum Chambers | 12/3/05 | West Coast | Grand Final | 4th | Ian Prendergast | 25/2/06 | Geelong | 1st Round | 3rd | Nick Stevens | 24/2/07 | Essendon | 1st Round | 1st | Eddie Betts | 3/3/07 | Hawthorn | Quarter Final | 1st | Marc Murphy | 10/3/07 | North Melb. | Semi Final | 1st | Brendan Fevola | 17/3/07 | Brisbane | Grand Final | 1st | Brad Fisher | 17/3/07 | Brisbane | Grand Final | 3rd | Andrew Carrazzo | 16/2/08 | Port Adelaide | 1st Round | 1st | Ryan Jackson | 23/2/08 | Hawthorn | Quarter Final | 2nd | Simon Wiggins | 23/2/08 | Hawthorn | Quarter Final | 2nd | Shaun Grigg | 23/2/08 | Hawthorn | Quarter Final | 3rd | Cameron Cloke | 23/2/08 | Hawthorn | Quarter Final | 4th | Nick Stevens | 20/2/09 | North Melb. | 1st Round | 1st | Brendan Fevola | 1/3/09 | Hawthorn | Quarter Final | 2nd | Brendan Fevola | 1/3/09 | Hawthorn | Quarter Final | 3rd | Marc Murphy | 26/2/12 | Port Adelaide | 1st Rd 1st Game | 1st Half | Matthew Kreuzer | 25/2/13 | Sydney | 1st Rd 2nd Game | 1st Half | Tom Bell | 9/3/13 | Adelaide | Semi Final / 3rd Round | 2nd | Brock McLean | 9/3/13 | Adelaide | Semi Final / 3rd Round | 2nd | Marc Murphy | 15/3/13 | Brisbane | Grand Final | 1st | Bryce Gibbs | 15/3/13 | Brisbane | Grand Final | 2nd | Zach Tuohy | 15/2/14 | North Melb. | 1st Round | 3rd | Zach Tuohy | 27/2/15 | West Coast | 1st Round | 4th | Zach Tuohy | 27/2/15 | West Coast | 1st Round | 4th | Cameron Wood | 15/3/15 | Collingwood | 2nd Round | 1st | Andrejs Everitt | 22/3/15 | Geelong | 3rd Round | 1st | Troy Menzel | 22/3/15 | Geelong | 3rd Round | 2nd | Matthew Watson | 28/2/16 | Essendon | 2nd Round | 3rd | Ed Curnow* | 9/3/16 | Sydney | 3rd Round | 4th | Zach Tuohy |