| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Gary Lawson-Smith | 1970 - 1971 | Came to the Blues as a Smith but left as a Lawson-Smith |
| Peter Bubner* | N/A | Pick 12 of the 1987 National Draft, he never came over |
| Tony Lynn | 1994 - 1996 | Originally from Queensland |
| Andrew Balkwill | 1997 | Single-gamer.... In M&M Blue! |
| Troy Menzel | 2013 - 2015 | Drafted in the 2012 National Draft from Golden Grove FC. |
| Corey Durdin | 2021 - ? | Drafted in the 2020 National Draft from Golden Grove FC. |
NB * denotes player did not play a senior game for Carlton