| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Rhoda McDonald | 1901 | Collingwood / South Adelaide |
| Mark Naley | 1987 - 1990 | 1987 Premiership Player / Sacred Heart College |
Carlton F.C. players who played with South Adelaide.
George & Kirk Kennedy, along with Sam Wallace were the founders of the South Adelaide Football Club in 1876. They were largely instrumental in the establishment of the S.A.F.A. (now S.A.N.F.L.) in 1877, its official formation preceded the V.F.A. by a few weeks. (See article below)
| Player | Era | Other Points | George D. Kennedy | 1876-1880 | Inaugural South Adelaide Captain. Carlton: 1868 - 1875 |
| Kirk Kennedy | 1876-1878 | Brother of George D. Kennedy. Carlton: 1879 |
| Sam A. Wallace | 1876- | Second captain of South Adelaide in 1881. Carlton: 1870 - 1875 |
| Billy Dedman | 1877-1880 | Topped South Adelaide goal kicking in 1877 (10 goals) and 1880 (9 goals). Dedman was also at Norwood. Carlton: 1871 - 1875 |
| Trent Hotton | 2000 - 2002 | East Burwood / Sth Adelaide / Collingwood / Preston / Warragul |
| Tom Fields | 2015 - ? | Originally from Labrador QLD |
Formation of South Adelaide & S.A.F.A. (S.A.N.F.L)
Trove; News (Adelaide) April 22 (p10) 1926