| Player | Era | Recruited From |
| Peter Cristoforo * | 1994 | Avondale Heights (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Daryl Platt * | 1995 | Gladstone Park (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| George Bakoulas * | 1997 | Tullamarine (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Damien Peverill * | 1997 | Keilor Park (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Marc O'Riley * | 1997 | Sunbury (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Luke McHardy * | 1997 | Keilor Park (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Kym Handley * | 1998 | Gisborne (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Kristian De Pasquale * | 1999 | Aberfeldie (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Adam Cusworth * | 1999 | Gisborne (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| David Johnson * | 1999 | Sunbury (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Anthony Franchina | 1997 - 2003 | Newlands-Coburg |
| Andrew Merrington | 2000 - 2003 | Strathmore |
| Adam Pickering | 2001 - 2002 | Craigieburn |
| Luke Saunders * | 2002 | Gisborne (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Ezra Bray * | 2002 | St Mary's NT |
| Jordan Bannister | 2004 - 2009 | Essendon / Calder Cannons / Therry-Penola |
| Adam Bentick | 2004 - 2009 | St Bernards (Niddrie) |
| Nick Becker * | 2005 | Strathmore (Rookie) |
| Eddie Betts | 2005 - 2013 | Mines Rovers FC WA / Mallee Park, SA / Templestowe (EFL) VIC |
| Jesse Smith | 2006 | Rupertswood |
| Brock McLean | 2010 - 2014 | Melbourne / Calder Cannons / Aberfeldie |
| Jeremy Laidler | 2011 - 2013 | Geelong / Calder Cannons / Doutta Stars |
| Matthew Watson | 2011 - 2015 | PEGS (Pascoe Vale) |
| Luke Mitchell | 2011 - 2013 | St Bernards |
| Frazer Dale | 2012 - 2013 | Assumption College / Myrtleford |
| Jayden Foster * | 2015 - 2016 | Aberfeldie |
| Matthew Dick | 2015 - 2016 | Sydney Swans / Calder Cannons / Macedon |
| Lachie Plowman | 2016 - 2023 | GWS Giants / Calder Cannons / Macedon |
| Andrew Gallucci * | 2016 - 2017 | Williamstown (VFL) / Calder Cannons / Strathmore |
| Sam Ramsay * | 2020 - 2021 | Gisborne |
| Callum Moore | 2020 | Richmond / Calder Cannons / Aberfeldie |
| Adam Saad | 2021 - ? | West Coburg / Calder Cannons / Coburg (VFL) / Gold Coast Suns / Essendon |
NB * Didn't, or is yet to play senior football with Carlton.