| Player | Era | Recruited From |
| Peter Crank * | 1992 | Frankston (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Brett Anthony * | 1994 | Mornington (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Ryan Aitken * | 1994 | Tyabb (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Garth Pickford * | 1996 | Hallam (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Shannon King * | 1996 | Frankston YCW (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Daniel Anderson * | 1996 | Somerville (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Daniel Marshall * | 1996 - 1997 | Frankston YCW |
| Toby Thurstans * | 1997 | Crib Point (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Darren Hulme | 1997 - 2004 | Frankston Bombers |
| Clint Evans * | 1998 | Berwick (Rookie) |
| Anthony Ferraro * | 1998 & 2001 | Karingal (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Craig Black * | 1998 - 1999 | Rosebud |
| Kris Massie | 1998 - 2001 | Edithvale - Aspendale |
| George De Crespigny * | 1999 | Berwick (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| James Hellweye * | 1999 | Karingal (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Brendan Fevola | 1999 - 2009 | Beaconsfield / Narre-Warren / Berwick |
| Michael Burke * | 2000 | Frankston East / Karingal (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Damian Orlando * | 2000 | Old Xaverians / Dandenong Stingrays / Berwick (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Craig Jacotine * | 2001 | Springvale (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Sheldon Fredricks * | 2001 | Noble Park (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Laurence Angwin | 2003 | Adelaide Crows / Box Hill Hawks / Dandenong Stingrays U/18's / Bonbeach |
| Michael Stinear * | 2003 | Beaconsfield / Carlton Rookie List |
| Anthony Raso * | 2005 - 2007 | Mt Eliza |
| Greg Bentley | 2009 | Port Power / Dandenong U/18's / Rosebud |
| Rohan Kerr * | 2010 - 2012 | Parkdale |
| Levi Casboult | 2010 - 2021 | Beaconsfield / Carlton Rookie List |
| Andrew McInnes | 2011 - 2014 | Devon Meadows |
| Andrejs Everitt | 2014 - 2016 | Sydney / Western Bulldogs / Dandenong U/18's / Somerville |
| Jacob Weitering | 2016 - ? | Mount Martha / Peninsula Grammar |
| Tom de Koning | 2018 - ? | Mount Martha |
| Matt Shaw | 2018 | Gold Coast Suns / Dandenong Stingrays / Chelsea & Carrum Junior FC |
| Will Setterfield | 2019 - 2022 | GWS Giants / Dandenong Stingrays / Caulfield Grammar / Edithvale-Aspendale / Albury FC (NSW), Scots School (NSW) |
| Nic Newman | 2019 - ? | Sydney Swans / Frankston (VFL) / Dandenong Stingrays / Mornington, Mt Martha JFC |
| Matt Cottrell | 2019 - ? | Pearcedale Senior FC |
| Jaxon Binns | 2023 - ? | Berwick / Caulfield Grammar |
| Billy Wilson * | 2024 - ? | Dromana FC |
NB * Didn't, or is yet to play senior football with Carlton.