| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Harvey Kelly | 1907 - 1909 | Also played at East Fremantle / Sth Melbourne / Graham Street Wesleys |
| Ernie Kelly | 1908 | Also played at East Fremantle |
| John Reilly | 1962 - 1965 | Also played for Footscray |
| Jon Dorotich | 1986 - 1993 | 1987 Premiership Player; 100 Games |
| Ricky Mott | 2004 | Also at the Swans |
| Cory McGrath | 2004 - 2006 | Also at Essendon |
| Josh Bootsma | 2012 - 2014 | Originally from South Coogee FC, WA. |
| Blaine Johnson | 2014 - 2015 | 2014 Rookie List / Kwinana JFC (originally played for Hobart JFC, Tasmania) |
| Jarrod Pickett | 2017 - 2019 | Jandakot JFC |
| Jarrod Garlett | 2018 - 2019 | Bibra Lake JFC |
| Jesse Motlop | 2022 - ? | South Coogee JFC / ​Aquinas College (WA). |
NB * Has yet to debut, or didnt play senior football with Carlton.