Player	Seasons at Carlton	Seasons at Essendon	Other Clubs
Jim Martin	1902	1907 - 1913	Fitzroy
Jim Cullen	1904	1899	South Melbourne
Joe Marr	1900 - 1902	1903	Nil
Fred Scott	1902 - 1904	1899 - 1901	Nil
Archie Snell	1902 - 1907	1908	Nil
Ted Kennedy	1904 - 1909	1901 - 1903	Nil
Jim Kennedy	1905 - 1907	1901	Nil
Frank Caine	1905 - 1909	1912 - 1914	Nil
Dick Harris	1906 - 1911	1905	St Kilda
Charlie Hay	1910	1911	Nil
Bill Johnson	1912	1907 - 1908	Nil
Justin McCarthy	1913 - 1914	1922 - 1926	Nil
Jack Woolley	1918 - 1919	1913 - 1914	Melbourne
Les Kittle	1919	1924	Nil
Clarrie Clowe	1920 - 1921	1922	Nil
Edric Bickford	1920 - 1922	1912	Nil
Ernie Martin	1923, 1925	1928 - 1929	St Kilda
Aub Charleston	1924 - 1925	1928	Nil
Jack Way	1925, 1927	1928	Nil
Bill Manger	1926	1925	Nil
Albert 'Jack' Williamson	1926	1929 - 1933	Nil
Jack Kidd	1931	1926 - 1930	Fitzroy
Steve Bloomer	1933	1934	North Melbourne
Norm le Brun	1935	1931 - 1932	Collingwood; South Melbourne
Bob Standfield	1942	1938 - 1940	Nil
Tom Leehane	1948	1950 - 1951	Nil
Ray Martini	1953	1950 - 1952	Nil
Brian Walsh	1970 - 1975	1975 - 1978	Nil
Peter Francis	1979 - 1981	1987 - 1988	Richmond; Fitzroy
Justin Madden	1983 - 1997	1980 - 1982	Nil
Glenn Hawker	1989 - 1991	1978 - 1988	Nil
Glenn Manton	1995 - 2003	1992 - 1994	Nil
Justin Murphy	1996 - 2000; 2002 - 2003	2004 - 2005	Geelong; Richmond
Matthew Allan	1994 - 2003	2004 - 2005	Nil
Cory McGrath	2004 - 2006	2001 - 2003	Nil
Jordan Bannister	2004 - 2009	2001 - 2003	VFL Umpire (2010 - 2011), AFL Umpire (2012 - 2016)
Scott Camporeale	1995 - 2005	2006 - 2007	Nil
Andrew D Phillips	2016 - 2019	2020 - ?	GWS
Adam Saad	2021 - ?	2018 - 2020	Gold Coast (2015 - 2017)
Will Setterfield	2019 - 2022	2023 - ?	GWS (2017 - 2018)

Links

Time at Other Clubs | A Summary of all Carlton v Essendon games