| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Sam Stivey | 1902 - 1903 | Boulder City |
| Arthur Ford | 1902 - 1903 | Boulder City / West Perth / Carlton / Essendon Town VFA |
| George Renwick | 1909 | Boulder City |
| Jack Wells | 1910 - 1914 | St Kilda / Midland Junction / Kalgoorlie |
| Henry Jane | 1911 | Kalgoorlie City |
| Clarrie Uren | 1924 | Kalgoorlie Railways |
| Ron 'Socks' Cooper | 1932 - 1942 | Nicknamed ‘Socks’ / Cottesloe / Albany WA |
| Ross Ditchburn | 1982 - 1983 | Claremont / Originally from Kukerin, WA |
| Brad Shine | 1985 - 1988 | Swan Districts / Originally from Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault, WA |
| Matt Clape | 1995 - 1998 | West Coast Eagles / East Perth / Originally from Margaret River JFC, WA |
| Eddie Betts | 2005 - 2023 & 2020 - 2021 | Mines Rovers FC WA / Mallee Park, SA / Templestowe (EFL) VIC / Calder Cannons |
| Josh Kennedy | 2006 - 2007 | East Fremantle / Originally from Northampton, WA |
| Paul Bower | 2006 - 2012 | Peel Thunder / Originally from North Mandurah, WA |
| Clinton Benjamin* | 2007 - 2008 | Claremont / Originally from Hale in Broome, WA |
| Jeffery Garlett | 2009 - 2014 | Swan Districts / Originally from Burracoppinn WA |
| Dennis Armfield | 2008 - 2017 | Swan Districts / Originally from Eastern Hills Hawks, Kalamunda WA |
| Josh Bootsma | 2012 - 2014 | South Fremantle / Originally from South Coogee FC, / Albany WA |
| Patrick Cripps | 2014 - ? | East Fremantle / Originally from Northampton / Moomiema, WA. |
| Blaine Johnson | 2014 - 2015 | South Fremantle / Originally from Kwinana WA |
| Blaine Boekhorst | 2015 - 2017 | Swan Districts / Originally from Port Headland WA |
| Bradley Walsh | 2015 | Peel Thunder / Originally from Rockingham JFC WA |
| Sam Petrevski-Seton | 2017 - 2021 | Claremont / Originally from Halls Creek (WA) |
| Zac Fisher | 2017 - 2023 | Perth / Originally from York (WA) |
| Mitch McGovern | 2019 - ? | Adelaide Crows / Claremont / Originally from North Albany (WA) |
| Jack Martin | 2020 - 2024 | Gold Coast Suns / Claremont / Originally from Towns FC (GNFL) (WA) |
| Jack Carroll | 2021 - ? | East Fremantle / Originally from Chapman Valley FC (GNFL) (WA) |
NB * denotes player is yet to, or did not play a senior game for Carlton.