| Player | Game | Details |
| T. Ennis | Round 10, 1896 | Goal with his first kick |
| Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp | Round 1, 1931 | Goal with his first kick |
| Harcourt Dowsley | Round 5, 1941 | Goal with his first kick |
| Clen Denning | Round 4, 1935 | Goals with his first 6 kicks! |
| Vin Waite | Round 5, 1966 | Goals with his first 2 kicks |
| Robert Walls | Round 2, 1967 | Goal with his first kick |
| Renato Serafini | Round 16, 1977 | Goal with his first kick (for Carlton) |
| Spiro Kourkoumelis | Round 17, 1981 | Goal with his first kick |
| Daryl Gilmore | Round 4, 1983 | Goal with his first kick - maybe his second? |
| Stephen Kernahan | Round 1, 1986 | Goal with his first kick |
| Mark Majerczak | Round 10, 1987 | Goal with his first kick |
| Tim Rieniets* | Round 6, 1990 | Goal with his first kick |
| Brett Ratten | Round 22, 1990 | Goal with his first kick |
| Matthew Allan | Round 15, 1994 | Goal with his first kick |
| Simon Beaumont | Round 10, 1995 | Goal with his first kick |
| Jacob Anstey | Round 7, 1997 | Goal with his first kick |
| Jonathon McCormick | Round 1, 2003 | Goals with his first 2 kicks |
| Laurence Angwin | Round 14, 2003 | Goal with his first kick |
| Setanta Ó hAilpín | Round 7, 2005 | Goal with his first kick |
| Bryce Gibbs | Round 1, 2007 | Goal with his first kick |
| Matthew Kreuzer | Round 3, 2008 | Goal with his first kick |
| Jeffery Garlett | Round 1, 2009 | Goal with his first kick |
| Luke Mitchell | Round 23, 2012 | Goal with his first kick |
| Dylan Buckley | Round 3, 2013 | Goal with his first kick |
| Dale Thomas | Round 1, 2014 | Goal with his first kick |
| Andrejs Everitt | Round 1, 2014 | Goal with his first kick |
| Jack Carroll | Round 7, 2022 | Goal with his first kick |
NB * denotes that there remains some doubt over Rieniet's goals with first kicks achievement. Whilst he kicked 2 goals 1 on debut, and we can confirm that the first goal was with his first kick, not even Tim himself can remember whether the second goal was with his second kick!