| Player | Seasons at Carlton | Seasons at the Eagles | Other Clubs |
| Peter Higgins | 1983 - 1985 * | 1989 | Nil |
| Matt Clape | 1995 to 1998 | 1992 - 1994 | Nil |
| Damian Hampson | 1991 - 1992 * | 1993 - 1994 | Nil |
| Callum Chambers | 2005 - 2006 | 2000 - 2004 | Nil |
| Chris Judd | 2008 - 2015 | 2002 - 2007 | Nil |
| Josh Kennedy | 2006 - 2007 | 2008 - 2022 | Nil |
| Sam Petrevski-Seton | 2017 - 2021 | 2022 - 2023 | Nil |
NB * Peter Higgins or Damien Hampson did not play a senior game at Carlton