| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Henry McPetrie | 1897 | Richmond City / St Kilda VFA / West Beach |
| William 'Mickey' Dunn | 1916 - 1919 | St George CYMS, SA |
| Phil Maylin | 1980 - 1984 | Woodville (SANFL) / Royal Park SA |
| Craig Bradley | 1986 - 2002 | Carlton Captain also played junior footy at Pooraka |
| Mark Naley | 1987 - 1990 | 1987 Premiership Player / Sacred Heart College |
| Jordan Russell | 2005 - 2012 | #9 Draft Pick (2004) - Top Ten Draft Pick. West Adelaide / Edwardstown, SA. |
| Adam Hartlett | 2007 - 2009 | #25 Draft Pick (2004) - Debuted in Round 9, 2007. West Adelaide / Edwardstown, SA. |
| Bryce Gibbs | 2007 - 2017 | #1 Draft Pick (2006) - Debuted in Round 1, 2007 - Glenelg / Plympton / Brighton HS |
| Mark Austin | 2007 - 2011 | #35 Draft Pick (2006) - Debuted in Round 22, 2007 - Glenelg / Brighton HS |
| Rhys O'Keeffe | 2009 - 2013 | #65 Draft Pick (2008) - Debuted in Round 14, 2011 - from Nth Adelaide / Kilburn |
| Patrick McCarthy | 2011 - 2013 | #34 Draft Pick (2010) - Glenelg / Plympton |
| Nick Duigan | 2011 - 2013 | #70 Draft Pick (2010) - Norwood / Pembroke College |
| Troy Menzel | 2013 - 2015 | #11 Draft Pick (2012) - Central Districts / Golden Grove |
| Cameron Giles * | 2014 - 2015 | #39 Draft Pick (2013) - Woodville-West Torrens / Originally from Prince Alfred College / Blythe Snowtown, SA |
| Cameron Wood | 2014 - 2016 | 2014 Rookie List / Williamstown (VFL), / Collingwood / Brisbane Lions / Goodwood Saints FC, SA |
| Matthew Wright | 2016 - 2018 | Traded as a Delisted Free Agent from the Adelaide Crows; originally from Walkerville (SA) / Nth Adelaide (SANFL) |
| Daniel Gorringe | 2016 - 2017 | Traded as a Delisted Free Agent from the Gold Coast Suns; originally from Tea Tree Gully (SA) / Norwood (SANFL) |
| Corey Durdin | 2021 - ? | #37 Draft Pick (2020) - Central Districts / Golden Grove FC. |
| George Hewett | 2022 - ? | Sydney Swans / North Adelaide (SANFL) / Prince Alfred College / Port Broughton. |
| Lewis Young | 2022 - ? | Western Bulldogs / Sturt (SANFL) / Mitcham (SA). |
| Harry Lemmey * | 2023 - ? | #47 Draft Pick (2022) - West Adelaide (SANFL) / Blackwood FC (SA). |
| Ashton Moir | 2024 - ? | #29 Draft Pick (2023) - Glenelg (SANFL) / Plympton FC (SA). |
| Orazio Fantasia | 2024 - ? | Payneham Norwood Union (SA) / Norwood (SANFL) / Essendon / Port Power. |
NB * Didn't, or is yet to play senior football with Carlton.