| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Ron 'Socks' Cooper | 1932 - 1942 | Nicknamed ‘Socks’ / Cottesloe / Albany WA |
| Ken Hunter | 1981 - 1989 | 3 time Premiership Player, originally recruited from Dalkeith Juniors |
| Ross Ditchburn | 1982 - 1983 | Originally from Kukerin, WA |
| Warren Ralph | 1984 - 1986 | Leading Goalkicker - 1984 |
| Wayne Blackwell | 1984 - 1990 | Originally from North Beach, Karrinyup Saints WA, Hale School WA, Best First Year Player - 1984 |
| Michael Aitken | 1985 | Originally from Floreat, WA. |
| Grant Povey* | 1988-1989 | Originally from Scotch College WA |
| Kelvin Holmes* | 1993 Pre-Season Draft | Did not come to Carlton |
| Clinton Benjamin* | 2007 - 2008 | Originally from Broome, WA Recruited 2006 National Draft |
| Sam Petrevski-Seton | 2017 - 2021 | Originally from Halls Creek, WA Recruited 2016 National Draft |
| Mitch McGovern | 2019 - ? | Originally from North Albany WA, also played at the Adelaide Crows |
| Jack Martin | 2020 - 2024 | Originally from Towns FC (GNFL) WA, also played at the Gold Coast Suns |
NB * denotes player did not play a senior game for Carlton.