| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Doug Fraser | 1910 | Via Yarraville, Victoria |
| Bruce Campbell | 1911 | Also played at Fitzroy and Melbourne |
| William Morgan | 1921 | Also played at South Melbourne |
| Brighton Diggins | 1938 - 1940 | Premiership Captain / Sth Melbourne |
| Jack Cooper | 1947 | N/A |
| Mike Fitzpatrick | 1975 – 1983 | Premiership Captain |
| Damian Hampson | 1991 - 1992 | Did not play a game for Carlton |
| Simon White | 2010 - 2017 | Picked up as a Rookie in the 2010 draft / Carine, WA |
| Josh Deluca | 2019 | Picked up in 2019 Mid-Season Rookie Draft / Sorrento Duncraig JFC (also played at Peel Thunder whilst at Fremantle Dockers) |
Vin Catoggio also had a stint at Subiaco in 1977.
Each of Diggins and Fitzpatrick were indeed recognised in the Subiaco Team of the Century announced in 2008.