Carlton defeated Fitzroy by 17 points at Brunswick Street Oval - despite being down by 5 goals at the last change.

Round 15, 1942

Carlton 3.0 18 3.6 24 7.7 49 17.13 115
Fitzroy 2.7 19 3.9 27 10.19 79 13.20 98
Venue: Brunswick Street
Date: Saturday 15 August 1942
Result: Win by 17 points
Crowd: 13,000
Goalkickers: J.Baird 7, J.Mooring 2, J.Wrout 2, R.Cooper 2, B.Chitty 2, O.Grieve 1, R.Savage 1.
Umpire: Morgan
Best: J.Mooring, J.Baird, V.Brown, G.Bailey, J.Francis, R.Savage, A.Sanger

Game Review

show_image.php?id=15623The stakes were high when the Blues and the Maroons met at the Brunswick Street Oval on this August Saturday afternoon. Sitting fifth and sixth respectively on the ladder, a loss by either side would have ended their finals aspirations, and the game was played accordingly.

Throughout the first half, it was a dour, defensive struggle, and at half-time Fitzroy led 3.9 (27) to Carlton 3.6 (24). With his side lacking spark, Carlton coach Percy Bentley rang the changes; sending his captain Bob Chitty from full-forward to centre half-back, and versatile defender Jim Baird from defence into the attacking goal-square. Baird gave the Blues a target, and booted two of Carlton's four goals for the quarter – but the Maroons got on top all over the field and, aided by a strong breeze, added 7.10 to lead by exactly five goals at the last change of ends.

A worried Bentley rallied his Blueboys, demanding more direct football to maximise the wind advantage, then watched on as his team grabbed the game by the scruff of the neck. With Chitty impassable across half-back, and the likes of Ron Cooper and Lance Collins pumping the ball forward, ‘Bones’ Baird began marking everything that came his way. He kicked another five spectacular goals for the term - finishing the match with seven - as the Blues came roaring back and vanquished a stunned Fitzroy by 17 points; 17.13 (115) to 13.20 (98). Popular 1938 Premiership defender Don McIntyre played his 100th and last match for the Blues that day, ending his career in unforgettable circumstances.

This set a new record for comebacks from three quarter time margins for Carlton, being the first time Carlton had ever come back from 30 points at three-quarter time. Carlton would match this feat only twice more in the next 66 years, but then the record would be smashed in 2008.

At the end of this round Carlton were in 5th spot on the ladder with a percentage of 116.6.


B: 2 Don McIntyre 12 George Gniel 17 Jim Baird
HB: 18 Arthur Sanger 5 George Bailey 9 Bob Atkinson
C: 15 Vin Brown 4 Lance Collins 8 Fred Fitzgibbon
HF: 19 Ron Cooper 28 Jack Wrout 31 Charlie McInnes
F: 10 Jim Francis (c) 6 Bob Chitty 23 Paul Schmidt
Ruck: 24 Ron Savage 26 Ollie Grieve 16 Jim Mooring (vc)
19th Man: 34 Cyril Mann
Coach: Percy Bentley


Boyles website ( www.boylesfootballphotos.net.au ) have identified the photo as Round 15 1942 and have named the players.
Back Row; George Gniel, George Bailey*, Ron Savage, Ron Cooper, Arthur Sanger, Jim Baird, Bob Atkinson*, Ollie Grieve
Middle Row; Vin Brown, Jack Wrout, Jim Mooring, Jim Francis, Bob Chitty, Charlie McInnes*, Don McIntyre
Front Row; Paul Schmidt, Fred Fitzgibbon*, Lance Collins*
Absent; 19th man, Cyril Mann
.* Most likely the player - Boyles unsure
These are the correct names, Blueseum has since found the named team photo from an article on Jack Wrout, from Peninisula Essence Feb 2021


Ron Cooper, Ollie Grieve


Rod McLean, ('flu), Jim Knight (refused leave from RAAF)


100th and Last Game: Don McIntyre transferred interstate with the RAAF
50 Games: Jim Mooring
Last Game Ron Cooper
Score Records: This set a new record for comebacks from three quarter time margins for Carlton, being the first time Carlton had ever come back from 30 points at three-quarter time. This effort was later matched in 1944 and 2008.

Round 14 | Round 16
Contributors to this page: blueycarlton , Jarusa , Bombasheldon , PatsFitztrick , molsey , timmyd , WillowBlue , camelboy , Mrs.O and admin .
Page last modified on Tuesday 11 of May, 2021 12:52:08 AEST by blueycarlton.

Online Users

123 online users
  • blueycarlton