| Player | Against | Round | Age |
| Damien Lock | Adelaide | Round 15, 1999 | 20 years, 282 days |
| Phil Poursanidis | Brisbane | Round 22, 1989 | 21 years, 116 days |
| Des Meadowcroft | Collingwood | Round 5, 1898 | 18 years, 64 days |
| Bill Strickland | Essendon | Round 5, 1900 | 17 years, 364 days* |
| Daryl Gutterson | Fitzroy | Round 10, 1971 | 18 years, 27 days* |
| Harold Rumney | Footscray | Round 7, 1926 | 19 years, 22 days |
| Karl Norman | Fremantle | Round 5, 2005 | 21 years, 328 days |
| Peter Gilbert | Geelong | Round 18, 1966 | 17 years, 238 days |
| Albert 'Jack' Williamson | Hawthorn | Round 12, 1926 | 19 years, 58 days* |
| Jim Martin | Melbourne | Round 15, 1902 | 17 years, 360 days |
| Alan Rayson | North Melb. | Round 11, 1943 | 18 years, 263 days |
| Trent Hoppner | Port Adelaide | Round 7, 1998 | 19 years, 79 days* |
| Jack King | Richmond | Round 13, 1929 | 18 years, 275 days |
| Ted Baker | St. Kilda | Round 10, 1920 | 19 years, 163 days* |
| Harry Gyles | Sth. Melb. | Round 2, 1897 | 16 years, 321 days* |
| Justin McCarthy | University | Round 12, 1914 | 19 years, 285 days |
| Darren Tarczon | West Coast | Round 9, 1992 | 21 years, 77 days |
-* Only Game