| Player | Era | Recruited From |
| Adam Saltalamacchia * | 1992 | Newcombe |
| Luke Rayner * | 1993 - 1994 | Grovedale |
| Dan Madden * | 1996 | St Joseph's (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Glenn Hanegraaf * | 1996 | Colac (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Drew Stevens * | 1996 | St Joseph's (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Kyle Nestor * | 1997 | South Warrnambool (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| James Rahilly * | 1997 | South Warrnambool (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Adam Wilkinson * | 1998 | Colac (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Tom Hall * | 1998 | North Shore (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Tim Van Der Klooster * | 1998 | Geelong Amateurs (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| James Dalton * | 1998 | Ocean Grove (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Quinton Gleeson * | 1999 | Koroit (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| David Haynes * | 1999 | North Warrnambool (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Ged Brody * | 1999 | Koroit (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Simon Fletcher | 1999 - 2003 | Geelong Reserves / Geelong Falcons / Grovedale |
| Sam Graham * | 2000 | Leopold (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Aaron Clark * | 2001 | Warrnambool (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Ben Jansen * | 2002 | Terang (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Dominic Gleeson * | 2002 | Koroit (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| Tim Muhlebach * | 2002 | Torquay (Reserves Top-Up Player) |
| David Clarke jnr | 2004 - 2005 | Geelong / Geelong Falcons / Torquay |
| Joseph Dare * | 2010 - 2011 | Colac (Rookie) |
| Lachlan Henderson | 2010 - 2015 | Brisbane Lions / Geelong Falcons / Geelong College / Birregurra |
| Ed Curnow | 2011 - 2023 | Box Hill Hawks / Adelaide Crows Rookie / Glenelg / Geelong Falcons / Geelong College / Modewarre |
| Fraser Russell * | 2015 | Geelong College (Category B Rookie) |
| Charlie Curnow | 2016 - ? | Torquay |
| Billie Smedts | 2017 | Geelong / Geelong Falcons / Nth Warrnambool |
| Darcy Lang | 2018 - 2020 | Geelong / Geelong Falcons / Colac |
| Sam Walsh | 2019 - ? | St Josephs / Cobden / Nightcliff (NT) |
| Hugh Goddard | 2019 - 2020 | St Kilda / Geelong Falcons / Melbourne Grammar / Geelong Amateurs |
NB * Didn't, or is yet to play senior football with Carlton.