| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Jim Davies | 1949 - 1950 | Was later president of the WAFL in the 1970's -80's |
| Mike Smith* | 1984 | Was reputedly the highest paid player at Carlton in his only year at the Blues |
| Brad Shine | 1985 - 1988 | Recruited from Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault. |
| Peter Kenny | 1986 | Also played for ACT club Manuka |
| Peter Sartori | 1987 - 1991 | Also played at Fitzroy |
| Stephen O'Reilly | 2000 | Also played at Fremantle and Geelong |
| Brett Johnson | 2004 - 2005 | Also played at Hawthorn |
| Luke Blackwell | 2006 - 2008 | Son of Wayne Blackwell |
| Dennis Armfield | 2008 - 2017 | Drafted in the 2007 National Draft |
| David Ellard | 2008 - 2015 | 2008 Rookie / from Guildford Grammar, WA |
| Chris Yarran | 2009 - 2015 | Drafted in the 2008 National Draft from Midvale Junior FC |
| Jeffery Garlett | 2009 - 2014 | Drafted in the 2008-09 Rookie Draft from Burracoppin FC | Wayde Twomey | 2011 | Drafted in the 2011 Rookie Draft originally from Werribee, Western Jets, Hoppers Crossing | Blaine Boekhorst | 2015 - 2017 | Drafted in the 2014 National Draft from Port Headland WA |
| Jesse Glass-McCasker * | 2016 - 2018 | Drafted in the 2015 Rookie Draft from Bassendean JFC / Guildford Grammar (WA) |
NB * denotes player did not play a senior game at Carlton