2024 Patrick Cripps (Vice Captain), Jacob Weitering
2023: Charlie Curnow
2022: Patrick Cripps (Vice Captain), Charlie Curnow, Adam Saad
2021: Sam Walsh, Harry McKay
2019: Patrick Cripps
2018: Patrick Cripps
2017: Sam Docherty
2011: Chris Judd (Vice Captain), Marc Murphy
2010: Chris Judd
2009: Chris Judd (Vice Captain), Brendan Fevola
2008: Chris Judd (Captain), Brendan Fevola
2006: Brendan Fevola
2004: Matthew Lappin
2001: Andrew McKay, Brett Ratten
2000: Scott Camporeale, Anthony Koutoufides, Andrew McKay, Brett Ratten, Lance Whitnall
1999: Matthew Allan, Andrew McKay, Stephen Silvagni
1997: Craig Bradley, Michael Sexton, Stephen Silvagni
1996: Michael Sexton, Stephen Silvagni
1995: Craig Bradley, Ang Christou, Anthony Koutoufides, Justin Madden, Stephen Silvagni, David Parkin (Coach)
1994: Greg Williams (Captain), Craig Bradley, Stephen Kernahan, Stephen Silvagni
1993: Craig Bradley, Andrew McKay, Greg Williams
1992: Mil Hanna, Stephen Kernahan
1990: Stephen Kernahan, Stephen Silvagni
1989: Stephen Kernahan
1988: Stephen Kernahan
1987: Mark Naley
1986: Stephen Kernahan, Craig Bradley
1984: Bruce Doull, Rod Ashman
1983: Des English, Ken Hunter
1982: Rod Ashman, Jim Buckley , Mike Fitzpatrick, Ken Hunter, David Parkin (Coach)
1980: Geoff Southby, Robbert Klomp
1979: Bruce Doull
1972: Alex Jesaulenko
1969: John Nicholls (Captain), Alex Jesaulenko
1966: John Nicholls, John Goold
1956: John Chick
1953: Jack Howell
NB From seasons 1953 to 1985, All-Australian selection was not awarded in most seasons.
Most Times All-Australian as Carlton Player
1. Stephen Kernahan, Stephen Silvagni: 6
3. Craig Bradley: 5
4. Chris Judd, Andrew McKay, Patrick Cripps: 4
6. Brendan Fevola: 3
All Australian Squad
2024: Charlie Curnow, Harry McKay
2023: Patrick Cripps, Jacob Weitering
2022: Jacob Weitering, Sam Walsh
2021: Jacob Weitering
2020: Jacob Weitering
2017: Matthew Kreuzer
2016: Sam Docherty, Kade Simpson
2014: Bryce Gibbs
2012: Eddie Betts
2011: Eddie Betts, Heath Scotland
2009: Marc Murphy
2023: Charlie Curnow
2022: Patrick Cripps (Vice Captain), Charlie Curnow, Adam Saad
2021: Sam Walsh, Harry McKay
2019: Patrick Cripps
2018: Patrick Cripps
2017: Sam Docherty
2011: Chris Judd (Vice Captain), Marc Murphy
2010: Chris Judd
2009: Chris Judd (Vice Captain), Brendan Fevola
2008: Chris Judd (Captain), Brendan Fevola
2006: Brendan Fevola
2004: Matthew Lappin
2001: Andrew McKay, Brett Ratten
2000: Scott Camporeale, Anthony Koutoufides, Andrew McKay, Brett Ratten, Lance Whitnall
1999: Matthew Allan, Andrew McKay, Stephen Silvagni
1997: Craig Bradley, Michael Sexton, Stephen Silvagni
1996: Michael Sexton, Stephen Silvagni
1995: Craig Bradley, Ang Christou, Anthony Koutoufides, Justin Madden, Stephen Silvagni, David Parkin (Coach)
1994: Greg Williams (Captain), Craig Bradley, Stephen Kernahan, Stephen Silvagni
1993: Craig Bradley, Andrew McKay, Greg Williams
1992: Mil Hanna, Stephen Kernahan
1990: Stephen Kernahan, Stephen Silvagni
1989: Stephen Kernahan
1988: Stephen Kernahan
1987: Mark Naley
1986: Stephen Kernahan, Craig Bradley
1984: Bruce Doull, Rod Ashman
1983: Des English, Ken Hunter
1982: Rod Ashman, Jim Buckley , Mike Fitzpatrick, Ken Hunter, David Parkin (Coach)
1980: Geoff Southby, Robbert Klomp
1979: Bruce Doull
1972: Alex Jesaulenko
1969: John Nicholls (Captain), Alex Jesaulenko
1966: John Nicholls, John Goold
1956: John Chick
1953: Jack Howell
NB From seasons 1953 to 1985, All-Australian selection was not awarded in most seasons.
Most Times All-Australian as Carlton Player
1. Stephen Kernahan, Stephen Silvagni: 6
3. Craig Bradley: 5
4. Chris Judd, Andrew McKay, Patrick Cripps: 4
6. Brendan Fevola: 3
All Australian Squad
2024: Charlie Curnow, Harry McKay
2023: Patrick Cripps, Jacob Weitering
2022: Jacob Weitering, Sam Walsh
2021: Jacob Weitering
2020: Jacob Weitering
2017: Matthew Kreuzer
2016: Sam Docherty, Kade Simpson
2014: Bryce Gibbs
2012: Eddie Betts
2011: Eddie Betts, Heath Scotland
2009: Marc Murphy