Coach: Col Kinnear
Captain: TBD
Best & Fairest: Brendan Hartney
Leading Goalkickers: Darren Ogier 59 goals (equal 6th in the comp.) and Warren Ralph 41 goals (equal 11th in the comp.)
Gardiner Medal: David Honybun 12 votes (5th place)
Position: 2nd
Premier: Melbourne
Round 1: March 31st 1984
Nth Melb. 19.14.128
Carlton 14.12.96
Result: Lost by 32 points
Goalkickers; Darren Ogier 4, Ian Muller 3, Warren 'Wow' Jones 1, Phil Maylin 1, Bruce Reid 1, Mike Smith 1, Shane Robertson 1, Peter Rohde 1, Gavin Exell 1.
Best; Ricky Nixon, Darren Ogier, Brendan Hartney, Shane Robertson, Ian Muller.
Round 2: April 7th 1984
Carlton played Fitzroy at the Junction Oval.
Carlton team;
Backs; Brendan Hartney, Mark Williams, Warren McKenzie
Half backs; Ricky Nixon, Bruce Reid, Rod Austin
Centres; Royce Enders, Peter Rohde, Jon Simpson
Half forwards; Mike Smith, Ian Muller, Wayne Blackwell
Forwards; Scott Howell, Darren Ogier, Mick Kennedy
Followers; Warren 'Wow' Jones, Phil Maylin
Rover; Shane Robertson
Interchange; Gavin Exell, Stephen Gumley, Andrew Graham
Umpires; Gale & Nolan
Fitzroy 24.22.166
Carlton 13.13.91
Result: Lost by 75 points
Goalkickers; Mike Smith 3, Shane Baldwin 2, Wayne Blackwell 1, Rod Austin 1, Jon Simpson 1, Peter Rohde 1, Mick Kennedy 1, Darren Ogier 1, Bruce Reid 1, Shane Robertson 1.
Best; Ricky Nixon, Wayne Blackwell, Rod Austin, Bruce Reid.
Carlton tenth, Won 0, Lost 2, Drawn 0, For 187, Against 294, 63.6%, Points 0
294,
Round 3: April 14th 1984
Carlton played Geelong at Princes Park at 11am.
Carlton team;
Backs; Brendan Hartney, Jamie Dunlop, Bruce Reid
Half backs; Andrew Graham, Mark Williams, Ricky Nixon
Centres; Mike Smith, Peter Rohde, Jon Simpson
Half forwards; Shane Baldwin, Scott Howell, Shane Robertson
Forwards; Giuseppe Lumicisi, Ian Muller, Stephen Gumley
Followers; Warren 'Wow' Jones, Phil Maylin
Rover; Mick Kennedy
Interchange; Darren Ogier, Royce Enders, Warren McKenzie
Emergency; David Krietemeyer
Umpires; Bullus & Waight
Geelong 19.16.130
Carlton 15.16.106
Result: Lost by 24 points
Goalkickers; Ian Muller 3, Darren Ogier 3, Mick Kennedy 2, Stephen Gumley 2, Scott Howell 2, Jon Simpson 1, Shane Baldwin 1, Shane Robertson 1.
Best; Scott Howell, Warren 'Wow' Jones, Brendan Hartney, Phil Maylin, Peter Rohde, Shane Robertson.
Round 4: April 21st 1984
Carlton played Richmond
Carlton team; (21 named plus emerg.)
From; Rod Ashman, Rohan Burke, Peter Dean, Garth Evans, Neil Gaghan, Stuart Glascott, Stephen Gumley, Brendan Hartney, David Honybun, Paul James, Mick Kennedy, David Krietemeyer, Warren McKenzie, Malcolm Mottram, Fraser Murphy, Ricky Nixon, Darren Ogier, Bruce Reid, Peter Rohde, Jon Simpson, Mark Williams.
Emergency; Shane Baldwin.
Carlton 14.14.98
Richmond 14.06.90
Result: Won by 8 points
Goalkickers; Mark Buckley 3, Darren Ogier 3, Stephen Gumley 1, Shane Baldwin 1, Phil Maylin 1, Peter Rohde 1, Peter Dean 1, Andrew Graham 1, Mick Kennedy 1, Fraser Murphy 1.
Best; Scott Howell, Bruce Reid, Brendan Hartney, Fraser Murphy, Peter Dean, Phil Maylin.
Round 5: April 25th 1984
Carlton 18.22.130
Collingwood 11.17.83
Result: Won by 47 points
Goalkickers; Mark Buckley 3, Stephen Gumley 3, Fraser Murphy 2, Darren Ogier 2, Peter Dean 2, Rod Ashman 2, Ian Muller 1, Peter Rohde 1, Ricky Nixon 1, Stuart Glascott 1.
Best; David Honybun, Darren Ogier, Mark Buckley, Brendan Hartney, Ian Muller, Mick Kennedy.
Round 6: May 5th 1984
Carlton 19.24.138
St Kilda 9.08.62
Result: Won by 76 points
Goalkickers; Darren Ogier 4, Stephen Gumley 4, Fraser Murphy 4, Neil Gaghan 2, Peter Rohde 1, Ricky Nixon 1, Mick Kennedy 1, Malcolm Mottram 1, Rohan Burke 1.
Best; Bruce Reid, Fraser Murphy, David Honybun, Mick Kennedy, Mark Williams.
Round 7: May 12th 1984
Carlton 21.17.143
Melbourne 14.16.100
Result: Won by 43 points
Goalkickers; Warren McKenzie 4, Tom Alvin 3, Darren Ogier 2, Justin Madden 2, Shane Robertson 2, Spiro Kourkoumelis 2, Mick Kennedy 1, Stephen Gumley 1, Ian Muller 1.
Best; Shane Robertson, Justin Madden, Rod Ashman, Tom Alvin, Stephen Gumley.
Round 8: May 19th 1984
Carlton 27.20.182
Hawthorn 17.14.116
Result: Won by 66 points
Goalkickers; Shane Robertson 5, Darren Ogier 5, Rod Ashman 4, David Honybun 3, Stephen Gumley 2, Spiro Kourkoumelis 2, Tom Alvin 2, Mark Buckley 2, Warren 'Wow' Jones 1, Ricky Nixon 1.
Best; Rod Ashman, Darren Ogier, David Honybun, Shane Robertson, Des English, Tom Alvin.
Round 9: May 26th 1984
Carlton 37.19.241
Essendon 9.14.68
Result: Won by 173 points
Goalkickers; Darren Ogier 8, Scott Howell 6, Fraser Murphy 5, Ian Muller 4, Spiro Kourkoumelis 4, Mark Buckley 3, Ricky Nixon 2, Warren 'Wow' Jones 2, Stephen Gumley 1, Tom Alvin 1, Royce Enders 1.
Best; Spiro Kourkoumelis, Darren Ogier, Fraser Murphy, Warren 'Wow' Jones, Scott Howell.
Essendon's Windy Hill scoreboard, an historic photograph.
According to the bigfooty web site, this is the Carlton Reserves highest score.
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/vfl-afl-reserves-under-19-records.747399/
Image: courtesy K. McNair
Round 10: June 3rd 1984
Carlton 34.12.206
Swans 10.11.71
Result: Won by 173 points
Goalkickers; Warren McKenzie 9, Darren Ogier 9, Stephen Gumley 4, Mick Kennedy 3, Wayne Harmes 2, Royce Enders 2, Andrew Graham 2, Shane Baldwin 2, Peter Dean 1.
Best; Peter Dean, Warren McKenzie, Darren Ogier, Wayne Harmes, Ricky Nixon, David Honybun.
Round 11: June 9th 1984
Footscray 19.15.129
Carlton 11.08.74
Result: Lost by 55 points
Goalkickers; David Glascott 2, Royce Enders 1, Darren Ogier 1, Mick Kennedy 1, Peter Rohde 1, Warren McKenzie 1, Ricky Nixon 1, Mike Smith 1, Val Perovic 1, Wayne Harmes 1.
Best; Brendan Hartney, Ricky Nixon, Warren McKenzie, Neil Gaghan.
Round 12: June 16th 1984
Carlton 10.21.81
Fitzroy 10.13.73
Result: Won by 8 points
Goalkickers; Mike Smith 2, Stephen Gumley 2, Brad Whitmore 2, Warren McKenzie 1, Mick Kennedy 1, Royce Enders 1, Stuart Glascott 1.
Best; David Honybun, Mick Kennedy, Brendan Hartney, David Glascott, Mike Smith, Neil Gaghan.
Round 13: June 23rd 1984
Geelong 15.08.98
Carlton 13.14.92
Result; Lost by 6 points
Goalkickers; Warren Ralph 4, David Honybun 2, Ian Muller 2, Neil Gaghan 1, Stephen Gumley 1, Warren McKenzie 1, Stuart Glascott 1, Mike Smith 1.
Best; Tom Alvin, Brendan Hartney, Shane Robertson, Neil Gaghan, Andrew Graham.
Reports: S.Reynoldson (Geelong) reported by field umpire Howlett for allegedly striking Ian Muller (Carlton) with a right fist to the face in the third quarter.
Round 14: June 30th 1984
Carlton 7.17.59
Richmond 7.09.51
Result; Won by 8 points
Goalkickers; Tom Alvin 2, Andrew Graham 2, Neil Gaghan 1, Warren McKenzie 1, Warren Ralph 1.
Best; Andrew Graham, Stephen Gumley, Brendan Hartney, Tom Alvin, Rod Austin, Mike Smith.
Round 15: July 7th 1984
Carlton 19.10.124
Collingwood 10.14.74
Result; Won by 50 points
Goalkickers; Warren Ralph 8, Shane Robertson 3, Ian Muller 2, Tom Alvin 2, Shane Baldwin 1, Mike Smith 1.
Best; Tom Alvin, Shane Robertson, Scott Howell, Ian Muller, Warren Ralph.
Round 16: July 21st 1984
St Kilda 13.09.87
Carlton 10.10.70
Result; Lost by 17 points
Goalkickers; Ian Muller 3, Darren Ogier 2, Rohan Burke 2, Andrew Graham 1, Jon Simpson 1, Neil Gaghan 1.
Best; Neil Gaghan, Peter Kenny, Geoff Southby, Mick Kennedy.
Round 17: July 28th 1984
Melbourne 18.10.118
Carlton 10.09.69
Result; Lost by 49 points
Goalkickers; Warren McKenzie 2, Warren Ralph 2, Darren Ogier 2, Scott Howell 1, Royce Enders 1, Stuart Glascott 1, Shane Robertson 1.
Best; Tom Alvin, Shane Robertson, Stuart Glascott, Peter Rohde, Mark Williams.
Round 18: August 4th 1984
Carlton 18.10.118
Hawthorn 10.09.69
Result; Won by 49 points
Goalkickers; Ken Sheldon 3, Warren McKenzie 2, Mike Smith 2, Stuart Glascott 2, Mark Williams 2, Wayne Harmes 2, David Honybun 2, Peter Rohde 1, Darren Ogier 1.
Best; Phil Maylin, Brendan Hartney, Warren McKenzie, Allan Montgomery, Peter Rohde, David Honybun.
Round 19: August 11th 1984
Carlton 18.19.127
Essendon 7.08.50
Result; Won by 77 points
Goalkickers; Warren Ralph 10, Fraser Murphy 2, David Honybun 1, Warren McKenzie 1, Ken Sheldon 1, Mike Smith 1, Mark Williams 1, Tom Alvin 1.
Best; Peter Rohde, Warren Ralph, Tom Alvin, Fraser Murphy, David Honybun, Mick Kennedy.
Round 20: August 18th 1984
Carlton 23.22.160
Nth Melb. 7.19.61
Result; Won by 99 points
Goalkickers; Mark Buckley 6, Warren Ralph 5, Peter Rohde 4,Mick Kennedy 2, Darren Ogier 1, Shane Robertson 1, Ken Sheldon 1, Mike Smith 1, Royce Enders 1, Stephen Gumley 1.
Best; Mark Williams, Mike Smith, Peter Rohde, Warren McKenzie, Shane Robertson, David Honybun.
Round 21: August 25th 1984
Carlton 14.14.98
Footscray 14.07.91
Result; Won by 7 points
Goalkickers; Warren McKenzie 4, Mark Buckley 2, Mark Williams 2, Shane Robertson 1, Darren Ogier 1, Ken Sheldon 1, Allan Montgomery 1, Mike Smith 1, Jon Simpson 1.
Best; Brendan Hartney, Shane Robertson, Warren McKenzie, Mick Kennedy, Allan Montgomery, Neil Gaghan.
Round 22: September 1st 1984
Carlton 21.13.139
Swans 11.12.78
Result; Won by 7 points
Goalkickers; Warren Ralph 6, Spiro Kourkoumelis 3, Warren McKenzie 3, Tom Alvin 2, Andrew Graham 2, David Glascott 2, Mike Smith 1, Shane Robertson 1, David Honybun 1.
Best; Scott Howell, Shane Robertson, Geoff Southby, Tom Alvin, Andrew Graham, Val Perovic.
1984 End of Home & Away Season Ladder
| Pos | Team | Wins | Losses | Draws | Points | For | Against | % |
| 1 | Melbourne | 17 | 5 | 0 | 68 | 2856 | 2252 | 126.8 |
| 2 | Carlton | 15 | 7 | 0 | 60 | 2652 | 2007 | 132.1 |
| 3 | Hawthorn | 15 | 7 | 0 | 60 | 2511 | 2114 | 118.8 |
| 4 | Fitzroy | 14 | 8 | 0 | 56 | 2818 | 2264 | 124.5 |
| 5 | Collingwood | 12 | 9 | 1 | 50 | 2538 | 2141 | 118.5 |
| 6 | Geelong | 12 | 10 | 0 | 48 | 2395 | 2218 | 108.0 |
| 7 | Nth Melb. | 10 | 12 | 0 | 40 | 2396 | 2634 | 91.1 |
| 8 | Footscray | 9 | 13 | 0 | 36 | 2269 | 2188 | 103.7 |
| 9 | Essendon | 9 | 13 | 0 | 36 | 2320 | 2658 | 87.3 |
| 10 | Swans | 7 | 14 | 1 | 30 | 2295 | 2671 | 85.9 |
| 11 | Richmond | 6 | 16 | 0 | 24 | 1994 | 2988 | 66.7 |
| 12 | St Kilda | 5 | 17 | 0 | 20 | 1951 | 2860 | 68.2 |
1984 Finals Series
Elimination Final
Collingwood 22.19.151 d Fitzroy 16.10.106
Qualifying Final
Carlton 27.11.173
Hawthorn 13.05.83
Result; Won by 90 points
Goalkickers; Darren Ogier 8, Shane Robertson 4, Warren McKenzie 3, Mark Williams 3, Spiro Kourkoumelis 2, Tom Alvin 1, Peter McConville 1, Peter Kenny 1, Peter Rohde 1, Stephen Gumley 1, Royce Enders 1, Mick Kennedy 1.
Best; Darren Ogier, Shane Robertson, Scott Howell, Spiro Kourkoumelis, Tom Alvin.
1st Semi Final
Collingwood 23.21.159 d Hawthorn 10.16.76
2nd Semi Final
Carlton 10.09.69
Melbourne 25.11.161
Result; Lost by 92 points
Goalkickers; Scott Howell 3, Warren McKenzie 3, Mark Buckley 1, Spiro Kourkoumelis 1, Royce Enders 1, Alex Marcou 1.
Best; Shane Robertson, Phil Maylin, Scott Howell, Mick Kennedy, Peter Rohde.
Preliminary Final
Carlton 17.18.120
Collingwood 7.10.52
Result; Won by 68 points
Goalkickers; Warren McKenzie 6, Warren Ralph 3, Peter Dean 2, David Honybun 1, Scott Howell 1, Mike Smith 1, Tom Alvin 1, Peter Rohde 1, Darren Ogier 1.
Best; Warren McKenzie, Shane Robertson, Peter Rohde, Neil Gaghan, Mark Williams, Brendan Hartney.
Video
Grand Final
Carlton 6.09.45
Melbourne 11.15.81
Result; Lost by 36 points
Goalkickers; Warren Ralph 2, Ken Sheldon 1, Warren McKenzie 1, Darren Ogier 1, Mick Kennedy 1.
Best; Brendan Hartney, Shane Robertson, Peter Rohde, Tom Alvin, Geoff Southby.
Reports:
Andrew Graham (Carlton) striking R.Ellingworth with both fists to the head in the fourth quarter
P.O'Brien (Melb) strking Scott Howell with both fists prior to the first quarter
Shane Robertson (Carl) on a charge of misconduct in that he jumped into the pack prior to the first quarter
J.Fidge (Melb) striking Ken Sheldon with both fists to the head in the first quarter
R.Ellingworth (Melb) attempting to strike Andrew Graham with both fists prior to the start of the fourth quarter
Darren Ogier (Carlton) striking D.Hughes with a clenched fist to the face prior to the start of the third quarter
R.Ellingworth (Melb) and Andrew Graham (Carlton) of attempting to strike each other with left and right fists prior to the start of the last quarter
P.O'Brien (Melb) striking Shane Robertson with left and right fists to the face and upper body prior to the start of the first quarter
P.O'Brien (Melb) striking Scott Howell with left and right fists to the stomach prior to the start of the third quarter
T.Fidge (Melb) striking Tom Alvin with a right fist to the head in the second quarter
R.Ellingworth (Melb) attempting to strike Andrew Graham prior to the start of the fourth quarter
Andrew Graham (Carlton) attempting to strike R.Ellingworth prior to the start of the fourth quarter
G.Boland (Melb) striking Mark Williams prior to the first quarter
R.Ellingworth (Melb) striking Andrew Graham prior to the start of the fourth quarter
Andrew Graham (Carlton) attempting to strike R.Ellingworth prior to the start of the last quarter
Mark Williams (Carlton) striking G.Boland prior to the first quarter