3rd in Carlton's Best and Fairest
Terry Ogden Memorial Trophy1951 Vin English
1953 Jack Mills
1954 Bruce Comben
Perc Bentley Trophy
1955 John Chick
1956 Peter Webster
1957 Doug Beasy
1958 John James
1959 John James
1960 Leo Brereton
1961 Serge Silvagni
1962 Murray Kick
1963 Wes Lofts
1964 John Nicholls
1965 John Goold
1966 Ron Barassi
1967 Serge Silvagni
1968 Garry Crane
1969 Bryan Quirk
1970 Vin Waite
1971 John Nicholls
1972 Trevor Keogh
1973 David McKay
1974 Trevor Keogh
1975 Robert Walls
1976 Peter Jones
1977 David McKay
1978 David McKay
1979 Geoff Southby
1980 Mike Fitzpatrick
1981 Mike Fitzpatrick
1982 Ken Hunter
1983 Des English
1984 Mark Maclure
1985 Mark Maclure
1986 Wayne Blackwell
1987 David Rhys-Jones
1988 Wayne Johnston
1989 Justin Madden
1990 Craig Bradley
1991 Andrew Phillips
1992 Adrian Gleeson
1993 Greg Williams
1994 Peter Dean
1995 Stephen Silvagni
1996 Michael Sexton
1997 Andrew McKay
1998 Brett Ratten
1999 Craig Bradley
2000 Anthony Koutoufides
2001 Matthew Lappin
2002 Craig Bradley
3rd in Carlton's Best and Fairest
2003 Brendan Fevola
2004 Matthew Lappin
2005 Lance Whitnall
2006 Heath Scotland
2007 Jarrad Waite
2008 Brendan Fevola
2009 Bryce Gibbs
2010 Marc Murphy
2011 Bryce Gibbs
2012 Chris Judd
2013 Lachie Henderson
2014 Kade Simpson
2015 Zach Tuohy
2016 Patrick Cripps
2017 Matthew Kreuzer
2018 Charlie Curnow & Ed Curnow
2019 Lachie Plowman
2020 Ed Curnow
2021 Harry McKay
2022 Sam Walsh
2023 Charlie Curnow