Coach: Rod Ashman
Captain: TBD
Best & Fairest: Michael James
Position: 8th
Premier: Brisbane Bears
Round 1 - Bye
Round 2: 30th March, 1991.
Carlton 20.11.131
Collingwood 15.12.102
Result: Won by 29 Points.
Goalkickers: David Rhys-Jones 5, Peter Sartori 3, Steven Oliver 2, Mark Bouw 2, Fraser Brown 2, Glenn Hawker 2, Michael James 1, Shane Robertson 1, Dom Fotia 1, Michael Sexton 1.
Best: Ian Aitken, Fraser Brown, Paul McMaster, Richard Dennis, Dom Fotia.
Round 3: 6th April, 1991.
Carlton 26.23.179
Brisbane 17.09.111
Result: Won by 68 Points.
Goalkickers: David Rhys-Jones 6, Peter Sartori 5, Steven Oliver 4, Dom Fotia 3, Ian Herman 2, Mark Majerczak 2, Glenn Hawker 1, Fraser Brown 1, Darren Tarczon 1, Fraser Murphy 1.
Best: Fraser Brown, Dom Fotia, David Rhys-Jones, Ian Aitken, Peter Sartori, Glenn Hawker.
Round 4: 13th April, 1991.
Carlton 18.15.123
Melbourne 12.11.83
Result: Won by 40 Points.
Goalkickers: David Rhys-Jones 6, Mark Arceri 3, Ian Aitken 2, Steven Oliver 2, Glenn Hawker 1, Dom Fotia 1, Peter White 1, Adrian Bassett 1, Ian Herman 1.
Best: Michael Sexton, Ian Aitken, Glenn Hawker, Dom Fotia, David Rhys-Jones.
Round 5: 20th April, 1991.
Geelong 16.09.105
Carlton 13.12.90
Result: Lost by 15 Points.
Goalkickers: Fraser Murphy 6, Ashley Matthews 4, Steven Oliver 2, Simon Minton-Connell 1.
Best: Michael Sexton, Simon Minton-Connell, Fraser Murphy, Glenn Hawker, Shane Robertson, Peter Doyle.
Round 6: 27th April, 1991.
Carlton 26.12.168
St Kilda 13.07.85
Result: Won by 83 Points.
Goalkickers: Fraser Murphy 5, Ashley Matthews 4, Fraser Brown 3, Peter White 3, Ian Herman 2, Ben Robertson 2, Adrian Bassett 1, Peter Doyle 1, Peter Sartori 1, Paul McMaster 1, Darren Tarczon 1, Chris Bond 1, Simon Minton-Connell 1.
Best: Michael James, Peter Sartori, Fraser Brown, Adrian Bassett, Shane Robertson, Darren Tarczon.
Round 7: 4th May, 1991.
Carlton 18.13.121
Essendon 13.09.97
Result: Won by 24 Points.
Goalkickers: Simon Minton-Connell 4, Ian Aitken 2, Ashley Matthews 2, Fraser Brown 2, Peter Sartori 2, Glenn Hawker 2, Peter Doyle 1, Luke O'Sullivan 1, Shane Robertson 1, Peter White 1.
Best: Michael James, Glenn Hawker, Shane Robertson, Fraser Brown, Steve Da Rui, Michael Sexton.
Round 8: 11th May 1991
Carlton 16.09.105
Hawthorn 11.04.70
Result: Won by 35 points
Goalkickers: Michael James 3, Peter Sartori 3, Chris Bond 2, Peter Doyle 2, Steven Oliver 2, Andrew Cavedon 2, Fraser Brown 1, Paul McMaster 1.
Best: Steven Oliver, Michael James, Steve Da Rui, Chris Bond, Michael Sexton, Darren Tarczon.
Round 9: 18th May 1991
Carlton 15.15.105
Richmond 19.12.126
Result: Lost by 21 points
Goalkickers: Paul McMaster 3, Peter White 2, Viv Romito 2, Fraser Brown 2, Richard Dennis 1, Luke O'Sullivan 1, Ashley Matthews 1, Fraser Murphy 1, Tim Rieniets 1, Darren Tarczon 1.
Best: Michael Sexton, Glenn Hawker, Darren Tarczon.
Reports: T.Esler (Rich) reported for striking Peter Doyle (Carl) in the second quarter.
Round 10: 25th May 1991
Bye
Round 11: 1st June 1991
Carlton 9.18.72
Footscray 4.08.40
Result: Won by 32 points
Goalkickers: Richard Dennis 2, Darren Tarczon 2, Mark Majerczak 1, Fraser Murphy 1, Viv Romito 1, Fraser Brown 1, Andrew Cavedon 1.
Best: Fraser Brown, Paul McMaster, Mark Majerczak, Andrew Cavedon, Darren Tarczon, Chris Bond.
Round 12: 8th June 1991
Bye
Round 13: 15th June 1991
Carlton 18.19.127
Sydney 7.12.54
Result: Won by 73 points
Goalkickers: Richard Dennis 5, Jon Dorotich 3, Tim Rieniets 2, Brett Ratten 2, Andrew Cavedon 2, Mark Majerczak 1, Ang Christou 1, Steven Oliver 1, Peter White 1.
Best: Ben Robertson, Tim Rieniets, Richard Dennis, Adrian Bassett, Andrew Cavedon.
Round 14: 22nd June 1991
Carlton 20.14.134
Brisbane 18.15.123
Result: Won by 11 points
Goalkickers: Jon Dorotich 4, Peter White 3, Ashley Matthews 2, Richard Dennis 2, David Glascott 2, Paul McMaster 2, Chris Bond 1, Stephen Edgar 1, Andrew Cavedon 1, Paul Meldrum 1, Ang Christou 1.
Best: Ian Aitken, Paul McMaster, Peter White, Andrew Cavedon, David Glascott, Ang Christou.
Round 15: 29th June 1991
Carlton 18.13.121
Fitzroy 8.12.60
Result: Won by 61 points
Goalkickers: Jon Dorotich 5, Peter White 4, David Glascott 3, Paul Meldrum 2, Richard Dennis 2, Peter Doyle 1, Paul McMaster 1.
Best: Ian Aitken, David Glascott, Peter White, Chris Mulcair, Peter Doyle, Steve Da Rui.
Round 16: 6th July 1991
Carlton 15.08.98
Nth Melb. 16.14.110
Result: Lost by 12 points
Goalkickers: Peter White 6, Chris Bond 2, Chris Mulcair 2, Paul McMaster 1, Michael James 1, Mark Majerczak 1, Anthony McDonald 1, Julian Shanks 1.
Best: Chris Bond, Andrew Cavedon, Peter White, Michael James, Damian Munivrana.
Round 17: 13th July 1991
Carlton 5.13.43
Collingwood 7.14.56
Result: Lost by 13 points
Goalkickers: Paul McMaster 2, Luke O'Sullivan 1, Michael James 1, Anthony Koutoufides 1.
Best: Michael James, Dom Fotia, Steve Da Rui, Danny Morgan, Mark Majerczak, Paul McMaster.
Round 18: 20th July 1991
Brisbane 17.15.117
Carlton 15.17.107
Result: Lost by 10 points
Goalkickers: Simon Minton-Connell 5, Paul Meldrum 2, Danny Morgan 1, Ben Robertson 1, Julian Shanks 1, Paul McMaster 1, Glenn Hawker 1, James Cook 1, Jeremy Smith 1, Dom Fotia 1.
Best: Michael Sexton, Richard Dennis, Paul Meldrum, Glenn Hawker, Danny Morgan, Dom Fotia.
Round 19: 27th July 1991
Melbourne 17.17.119
Carlton 8.07.55
Result: Lost by 64 points
Goalkickers: James Cook 2, Chris Mulcair 1, Julian Shanks 1, Ben Robertson 1, David Glascott 1, Andrew Cavedon 1, Richard Dennis 1.
Best: Richard Dennis, Danny Morgan, Ashley Matthews, Andrew Cavedon.
Round 20: 3rd August 1991
Carlton 11.14.80
Geelong 19.18.132
Result: Won by 52 points
Goalkickers: Simon Minton-Connell 5, Chris Bond 2, Andrew McKinnon 1, Adam Henry 1, Matheu Quirk 1, Jeremy Smith 1.
Best: Ashley Matthews, Chris Bond, Chris Mulcair, Craig Hucker, Simon Minton-Connell, Adam Henry.
Round 21: 10th August 1991
Carlton 7.05.47
St Kilda 19.18.132
Result: Lost by 85 points
Goalkickers: Simon Minton-Connell 3, Glenn Hawker 3, Ang Christou 1.
Best: Ben Robertson, Anthony Koutoufides, Ashley Matthews.
Round 22: 17th August 1991
Carlton 14.12.96
Essendon 19.07.121
Result: Lost by 25 points
Goalkickers: Simon Minton-Connell 5, Anthony Koutoufides 3, Craig Hucker 2, Ben Robertson 1, Paul Pezzin 1, Matheu Quirk 1, Ang Christou 1.
Best: steve Da Rui, Dom Fotia, Craig Hucker, Ben Robertson, Simon Minton-Connell, Damian Hampson.
Round 23: 24th August 1991
Carlton 17.06.108
Hawthorn 17.14.116
Result: Lost by 8 points
Goalkickers: Anthony McDonald 3, Ang Christou 3, Craig Hucker 3, Anthony Koutoufides 2, Dom Fotia 2, Adam Henry 2, Jerry Martinov 2.
Best: Anthony Koutoufides, Ang Christou, Ben Robertson, Dom Fotia, Damian Hampson, Steve Da Rui.
Round 24: 31st August 1991
Carlton 12.07.79
Richmond 17.16.118
Result: Lost by 39 points
Goalkickers: Ben Robertson 3, Chris Mulcair 3, Paul McMaster 2, Ashley Matthews 1, Glenn Hawker 1, Paul Pezzin 1, Jerry Martinov 1.
Best: Steve Da Rui, Glenn Hawker, Ben Robertson, Danny Morgan.
Ladder end of 1991 Reserves Home & Away Season.
| Pos | Team | Wins | Losses | Draws | Points | For | Against | % |
| 1 | Collingwood | 17 | 5 | 0 | 68 | 2705 | 2027 | 133.4 |
| 2 | Melbourne | 15 | 7 | 0 | 60 | 2923 | 2314 | 126.3 |
| 3 | Brisbane | 14 | 8 | 0 | 56 | 2488 | 2366 | 105.1 |
| 4 | Geelong | 13 | 9 | 0 | 52 | 2625 | 2183 | 120.2 |
| 5 | Nth Melb. | 13 | 9 | 0 | 52 | 2556 | 2346 | 109.0 |
| 6 | St Kilda | 12 | 10 | 0 | 48 | 2347 | 2042 | 114.9 |
| 7 | Hawthorn | 11 | 11 | 0 | 44 | 2394 | 2171 | 110.3 |
| 8 | Carlton | 11 | 11 | 0 | 44 | 2284 | 2138 | 106.8 |
| 9 | Richmond | 10 | 12 | 0 | 40 | 2281 | 2456 | 92.9 |
| 10 | Essendon | 10 | 12 | 0 | 40 | 2025 | 2425 | 83.5 |
| 11 | Fitzroy | 6 | 16 | 0 | 24 | 1984 | 2617 | 75.8 |
| 12 | Footscray | 5 | 17 | 0 | 20 | 1859 | 2588 | 71.8 |
| 13 | Sydney | 5 | 17 | 0 | 20 | 1972 | 2770 | 71.2 |
1991 Reserves Finals Series
Qualifying Final
Collingwood 17.10.112 d Melbourne 15.9.99
First Elimination Final
St Kilda 23.14.152 d Nth Melbourne 15.13.103
Second Elimination Final
Brisbane 25.13.163 d Geelong 11.16.82
1st Semi Final
Melbourne 17.14.116 d St Kilda 11.8.74
2nd Semi Final
Brisbane 17.14.116 d Collingwood 12.8.80
Preliminary Final
Melbourne 19.11.125 d Collingwood 9.10.64
Grand Final
Brisbane 16.13.109 d Melbourne 11.9.75