| Player | Era | Recruited From |
| Bill Collins | 1899 - 1900 | Rutherglen Rovers |
| Harry Thompson | 1899 | St Kilda / Beechworth |
| Harry Evans | 1899, 1901 | Rutherglen |
| Charlie Roland | 1900 - 1908 | Chiltern / Rutherglen |
| Joe Sullivan | 1900 - 1903 | Rutherglen / Port Melb. / Collingwood VFA / Collingwood Imperials |
| Henry Crisfield | 1902 | Rutherglen |
| Paddy Leahy | 1902 | Murchison |
| Jim Flynn | 1903 - 1910 | Geelong / Benalla District / Collingwood VFA / Canterbury |
| Albert Trim | 1903 - 1904 | Sth Melb. / Beechworth |
| Pat Pelly | 1904 | St James (near Yarrawonga) |
| Jim Slater | 1905 | Wangaratta |
| Andy Kennedy | 1906 | Benalla |
| William Harry | 1906 | Rutherglen |
| Charlie Meadway | 1906 | Wangaratta |
| Bill Hickey | 1907 | Sth Melbourne / Wangaratta |
| Andy Pattison | 1908 - 1909 | Caniambo (near Shepparton) |
| Jack Baquie | 1909 - 1913 | Seymour / Melbourne / Brunswick |
| Tom McCluskey | 1910 | Shepparton |
| Archie Wilson | 1910 - 1913 | Tatura |
| Fen McDonald | 1911 - 1912 | Nagambie |
| Gordon Green | 1911 - 1921 | St James (Yarrawonga) |
| Pat Ryan | 1913 | Dookie |
| Arthur Harrison | 1914 | Cobram |
| Jack Lowe | 1914 | Collingwood / Seymour |
| Jimmy Morris | 1914 - 1917 | Shepparton |
| Charlie Fisher | 1914 - 1921 | Kyabram |
| Dave Crone | 1917 - 1920 | Fitzroy / South Ballarat / Donald |
| Jack Greenhill | 1917 - 1923 | Corryong |
| Frank Martin | 1917 - 1923 | Avenel |
| Joe Prince | 1919 | Sth Melb. / St Kilda / Preston / Rose of Northcote / Avenel |
| Les Kittle | 1919 | Shepparton |
| Newton Chandler | 1919 - 1924 | Brunswick / Porepunkah (Bright) |
| Croft McKenzie | 1920 - 1923 | Numurkah / Wesley College |
| Rupe Hiskins | 1920 - 1924 | Rutherglen |
| Jim Fraser | 1922 - 1923 | Mansfield |
| Charlie Greenhill | 1922 | Corryong |
| Eric Humphrey | 1922 | Corryong |
| Frank Pritchard | 1922 - 1923 | Tatura |
| Roy Dick | 1923 | Tatura |
| Clyde Hill | 1923 | Mooroopna (Shepparton) |
| Pat Kennedy | 1923 - 1925 | University Blacks / Newman College / Sth Melb CYMS / Cobram |
| George Robbins | 1925, 1929 | St Kilda / Rutherglen / Wesley College |
| Maurie Connell | 1925 - 1929 | University Blues / Brighton / Newman College / Sth Melbourne / Yarrawonga / St Pat's Ballarat |
| George Hawking | 1927 | Rushworth |
| Denis Kelleher | 1927 - 1932 | Wangaratta |
| Allan Skehan | 1927 - 1929 | Wangaratta |
| Jack Kidd | 1931 | Tungamah / Essendon |
| Charlie Street | 1932 - 1933 | Richmond / St James (Yarrawonga) / Nth Richmond |
| Jack Cooper | 1933 - 1935 | Tungamah |
| Harry Hollingshead | 1936 - 1940 | Seymour / Kilmore |
| Bob Chitty | 1937 - 1946 | Cudgewa / Sunshine / Fairfield (Wodonga) |
| Vin Brown | 1941 - 1948 | Thornbury CYMS / Yea |
| Harold McDonald | 1944 | Nagambie |
| Arthur Hall | 1945 | Fitzroy / Benalla All Blacks |
| Wal Alexander | 1945 - 1947 | Wodonga / Parkville Juniors / Footscray District |
| Ray Garby | 1946 - 1950 | Cohuna / Assumption College / AIF |
| Max Howell | 1948 - 1950 | Benalla |
| Allan White | 1957 - 1959 | Avenel |
| Len Cottrell | 1958 - 1959 | Myrtleford / Toowonga |
| John Stephenson | 1958 | Benalla |
| Barry Bryant | 1960 - 1961 | Kyabram / Walwa (Corryong) |
| Barry Smith | 1960 | Tatura |
| Ian Nankervis | 1964 - 1966 | Mildura Imperials / Dookie / Shepparton |
| John Lloyd | 1965 - 1967 | Yarrawonga |
| Ron Stone | 1965 - 1969 | Wangaratta Combined Churches |
| Brian Kekovich | 1967 - 1968 | Myrtleford |
| Dennis Munari | 1967 - 1970 | Assumption College Kilmore |
| Ian Nicoll | 1967 - 1970 | Wangaratta Rovers |
| Peter Warburton | 1971 - 1972 | Tatura |
| Renato Serafini | 1977 - 1978 | Fitzroy / Assumption College Kilnore |
| Michael Garvey | 1988 - 1989 | Wodonga |
| Paul Payne | 1989 | Tatura |
| Tim Rieniets | 1990 - 1991 | Coburg / Nth Melb. Reserves / Wangaratta Rovers / Wangaratta College FC |
| Tim Powell | 1993 - 1994 | Richmond / Assumption College Kilmore / Berrigan, NSW |
| Adrian Whitehead | 1994 - 1999 | Federal (Upper Murray FL) / Wodonga (Ovens & Murray FL) |
| Dean Rice | 1994 - 2001 | St Kilda / Geelong Reserves / Longwood / Essex Heights |
| Mark Porter | 1997 - 2001 | Coburg / Wangaratta / King Valley |
| Murray Vance | 1999 - 2001 | Murray Bushrangers U/18's / Shepparton United |
| Matthew Lappin | 1999 - 2007 | St Kilda / Chiltern |
| Ryan Houlihan | 2000 - 2011 | Murray Bushrangers U/18's / Corowa-Rutherglen / Wahgunyah |
| Sean O'Keeffe | 2002 - 2003 | Murray Bushrangers U/18's / Wangaratta Rovers / Centrals Junior FC / Glenrowan |
| Justin Davies | 2002 - 2005 | Murray Bushrangers U/18's / Shepparton United / Shepparton East |
| Jonathon McCormick | 2003 - 2004 | Murray Kangaroos / Murray Bushrangers U/18's / Wangaratta / Wangaratta Junior Magpies |
| Karl Norman | 2003 - 2005 | Wangaratta Rovers / Glenrowan |
| Jarrad Waite | 2003 - 2014 | Murray Bushrangers U/18's/ Benalla |
| Glen Bowyer | 2004 - 2005 | Hawthorn / Murray Bushrangers U/18's/ Wodonga |
| David Teague | 2004 - 2006 | Nth Melb. / Murray Kangaroos / Murray Bushrangers U/18's/ Katandra |
| Frazer Dale | 2012 - 2013 | Calder Cannons U/18's/ Assumption College / Myrtleford / Myrtleford Saints |
| Sam Rowe | 2012 - 2018 | Walla Walla NSW, Nth Albury NSW, Murray Bushrangers, Sydney Rookie, Norwood, SA |
| Nick Holman | 2014 - 2015 | Murray Bushrangers, Kyabram |
| Mark Whiley | 2015 - 2016 | GWS Giants, Murray Bushrangers, Finley (NSW) |
| Caleb Marchbank | 2017 - 2024 | GWS Giants, Murray Bushrangers, Benalla |
| Will Hayes | 2022 | Carlton (VFL) / Western Bulldogs / Sandringham Dragons / Melbourne Grammar / Euroa |
| Oliver Hollands | 2023 - ? | Murray Bushrangers (TAC) / Wondoga Bulldogs (VCFL) |
| Elijah Hollands | 2024 - ? | Gold Coast Suns / Murray Bushrangers (TAC) / Caulfield Grammar / Wondoga Bulldogs (VCFL) |
(Cached)