Our first full year of competition


Carlton would be a leader of the 'Melbourne Rules' competition.

Over the 12 years of participation in the 'Melbourne Rules' prior to joining the VFA in 1877, Carlton would be a formidable presence with 5 Premierships, 3 Runner-Ups and would never fall below third.

Carlton Captain. Harry Chadwick.
President. R. McFarland
Secretary. B. James.
Home Ground. Royal Park.
The Challenge Cup Competition.
Membership 40.

The Bairnsdale Advertiser February 3, 1915
"Fifty years ago the Carlton Football Club had a membership of 40. Now it has 5,000 members.
There was £8 in hand to start the season in 1865. Seven pounds sufficed for the year's requirements, and £1 was carried forward. It now takes many hundreds of pounds to meet one item - payment to players."

Carlton resolved upon it's "uniform" this year to wear a blue band on it's orange cap.

A body known as the Athletic Sports Committee offered a football Challenge Cup and bought to the Australian code the first touch of organisation it had known.
The Athletic Sports Committee arranged the order in which challenges should be accepted.

Clubs competing for Challenge Cup.
Carlton, Melbourne, Geelong, South Yarra, Royal Park, and University.

Clubs also played matches outside this competition.

According to wikipedia in 1865 Melbourne's population overtook Sydney to be the largest city in Australia.


April 25


This classified advert. is from the Herald April 25 (p4) 1865.
There is a thought that the club was formed in 1865 at the University Hotel meeting on May 17.
This advert predates that meeting and has Ben James as Hon. Sec. not as "acting Hon. Sec.". This indicates the football club was already formed, possibly as far back as 1861. See Formation of the Club
The Carlton Cricket Club also was called the Carlton Union Cricket Club, the Union name was dropped later in 1865.

May 17 Wednesday
"A meeting of the Carlton Football Club, was held at the University Hotel, last Wednesday, for the purpose of electing office bearers for the season, and adopting a code of rules for the guidance of the club. Mr. Waugh occupied the chair. The secretary was requested to communicate with James Linacre, Esq., asking him to accept the office of president of the club. Mr. John Walls was duly elected vice president; and the following gentlemen the committee, namely: - Messrs Waugh, McLean, McHarg, Richardson, Bowen, Byrne, McFarland and Adamson. Mr. B. James secretary.
After some consideration it was resolved to adopt the Melbourne Club rules."
(Trove: Age May 19 p5)

May 24 Wednesday
"A scratch match of football will be played among members of the Carlton Football Club today at 2.30." (Herald p2)

1857 Myall Hotel advert courtesy Picture Victoria ID: 14907

Prahran area from 1868 Sands and McDougall map SLV
The Warehousesman's or Albert Cricket Ground is marked near the "K" of Albert Park. (although the present ground is slightly closer to Commercial Road)
The Myall Ground is where Race Course is marked on Commercial Road between St.Kilda and Punt Roads.
Much of this site is now occupied by the Alfred Hospital

Looking west from the Prahran Town Hall in 1867. The building top far right is possibly the rear of the Myall Hotel on Punt Road.
An interesting photo, High Street road-over-rail bridge and Morrow's Hotel on High Street can be seen.
Also the short lived rail loop from St.Kilda to Windsor can be seen. Embankment, rail bridges over Punt and St.Kilda roads and in the far distance, a huge curving trestle railway structure in Albert Park.
Building top far left is the Park View Hotel in Peel Street Windsor.
Photo courtesy of the Stonnington Historical Society. Victoria ID: 2213.42
There was a cricket ground opposite the Myall Hotel (Bells Life March 05 p2 1859)
The Comet Cricket Club had a ground near the Myall Hotel (Argus March 01 p6 1859)

"The building opposite the school was the Myall Hotel, used in the early days, hence the name Myall Green.
There were no buildings on this green from High-street to Commercial-road in the sixties, and was sometimes called Chamber's paddock on the account of Chambers large iron foundry, one of the first in Melbourne, which after his death by accident was closed and sold. The Myall Hotel was bought by the Honorable George Fairbanks in 1890, and the Fawkner Flats were built on the site."
(The Age October 05 1935 p7)
Enoch Chambers built his iron foundry off Charles Street, in Foundry Lane. The first railway locomotive in Victoria was built in this foundry. (Prahran Telegraph 24 February 1906 p6)
Charles Street runs parallel to the South Yarra - Windsor railway line on the west side and is probably the street closest to the rail line in this photo.

May 27


Carlton played Melbourne Grammar School on the Myall Ground opposite the Warehouseman's Cricket Ground.
The Warehouseman's Cricket Ground is now known as the Albert Ground on St.Kilda Road.
Some old Melbourne and suburban maps show a cricket ground to west of the Warehousemans Ground which would now be in the Albert Park golf course Queens Road area. Was this the Myall Ground?

There was a Myall Hotel, (the second hotel built in the Prahran area) on the south east corner of Punt and Commercial Roads. The hotel had a 6 acre parcel of land attached to it. This paddock was called the Myall Green. Regular sporting events were held on this allotment and could have been the Myall ground that Carlton played on.
The Argus 26 July 1921 (p4) mentions Myall Green being opposite the Myall Hotel which stood on the south east corner.
In 1860 a government reserve ran between St.Kilda Road to Punt Road bounded on the north side by Commercial Road. Today the Alfred Hospital occupies much of this land.
In 1865 horse racing was held in Fawkner Park, opposite the Myall Hotel.
The Prahran Telegraph October 16 1897 (p5), "The first race course in Prahran was opposite the Myall hotel on the site of the Alfred Hospital ..."
The Fawkner Flats or "Mansions" were built on the hotel site around 1890. These were later turned into nursing homes for the Alfred Hospital, which later became rooming homes that fell into disrepair.
The latest google street view (viewed Sept. 2020) shows the vacant red brick building still standing.

Herald May 27 p20

The players met at Princes Bridge at a quarter to two.
This is the earliest Carlton team squad yet found and some say Carlton's first match.
However, there is anecdotal evidence that the Blues played matches in earlier years. See Formation of the Club.
Carlton team; (27 named)
Chadwick, Adamson, Bowen, Buchan, Byrne, Duncan, Fargher/Farquhar?, Gaggin, Gordon, Gorman, Greeve/Green?, Guy, Hewitt, Hillsden, Horan, James, McCracken, McFarland, McHarg, Orlando O'Brien, Tom Power, J/R. Richardson, Tinlay/R. Finlay? George A. Waugh, M. Webb, Jim Williams, Bill Williams.
Match drawn 0 - 0
Blueseum has put the players in alphabetical order, except for Chadwick. The Herald May 27 (p2) named Chadwick first of the 27 mixed names. Was he possibly captain?
The names of Farquhar, Green, R. Richardson, R. Finlay appear in Vol 1 of O.O.A.F. (p220) the other spellings are possibly newspaper misprints.
Other information Blueseum has found is that in the formative years of the club, a player was chosen as captain on the day.
A 1924 Herald article by C. C. Mullens - Sixty Years, mentions Chadwick and Hillsden as early captains. See Formation Of The Club

May 29


"A report of the Health Committee recommends the granting of permissive occupancy on a piece of land between the Sydney road, Madeline street and Cemetery Crescent, by the Carlton Cricket Club, on certain conditions. Clause 24 of the Public Heath Statute, 1865, is also to brought under the notice of the council." (Herald p2)
(Madeline Street is now known as Swanston Street)

June 03
No details


June 10
Classified Advertisment.
FOOTBALL- Warehousemen v Carlton Union,
The Argus, (page 8)
Most certainly the Carlton Football Club.
The Carlton Cricket Club was also known as the Carlton Union in it's early days until September 1865.

The Warehouseman were dock warehouse/storemen, the forerunners to the Waterside Workers or "wharfies". Their home ground was the Warehousemans Ground which is now called the Albert Ground and is situated on St.Kilda Road.

The Age June 10 (p5); A football match between the Carlton and the Warehouseman's clubs will be played this afternoon in the Prince's Park, near the cemetery, the game to commence at two o'clock. The Carlton team will be selected from the following, viz:
Carlton team; (26 named)
Dave Adamson, George F. Bowen, James Byrne, Harry Chadwick, J. Clark/e, Jim C. Duncan, Fargher/Farquhar?, Gorman, Green, Harry Guy, Harper, Frank Hillsden, James Horan, Ben James, Lucas, Robert H. McFarland, Andrew W. McHarg, Jack McHarg, Orlando O'Brien, Phillips, Tom Power, J. Richardson, George A. Waugh, M. Webb, Jim Williams, Bill Williams.
The Age;
"At the Royal-park, the Warehouseman's Club met the Carlton Club, and here too a close game was played, neither side succeeding in kicking a goal, though the game was continued till the coming night rendered it impossible to proceed further. On both grounds the drizzling rain, which began to fall about four o'clock, rendered foothold after that hour very precarious, and, as a consequence, some of the players got ugly falls-one, at the Royal Park, having the misfortune to break the cartilage of his nose."
Match drawn 0-0

June 17


The Leader newspaper (p2);
"Football, which last winter was much neglected for that class of community to whom out-door sports are almost a necessity, seems this year to regaining something of the position to which it is entitled in the list of manly pastimes. On Saturday two very interesting and closely contested matches were played."
The two matches referred to were the Civil Service vs Customs Department and the Carlton vs the Warehouseman's Club.

Football had been on a gradual decline since the first few years of the game. The patrician clubs of Melbourne, South Yarra, and to some extent the provincial Geelong Club with its Geelong Grammar background did not appeal to the masses of the metropolis. With the advent of the Carlton Football Club and it's the working class connections, the club soon became competitive against the earlier established clubs.
The Carlton - Melbourne rivalry would soon fire the imagination of Melbournians and draw record crowds. These two clubs' matches would over the next decade firmly place Australian Football to the fore in the public's eye, with the continuing dominance of Australian Football to the present day.

June 17
No details

June 24
No details
The Age said that only scratch matches were played on the football grounds.


July 01
From The Argus, (page 8)
FOOTBALL- Royal Park v Carlton-MATCH THIS AFTERNOON, Park ground. R. Waugh hon.sec. Royal Park.
To be Blues named in the Royal Park team, G. Kennedy, J. Kennedy, T. Marshall, W. Marshall

Bell's Life newspaper reported that Royal Park won 2-0, with the last goal being disputed.
A letter to the paper a few days later by a person called "Orange and Blue"* says the published result is incorrect, and that the match was drawn, "If they had won two goals on 1st. July, what game could be played out on the 8th?"
In the early days of football two goals was required to win a match, a score line of 1-0 was a draw and if possible the match replayed the following week.
The book the Centenary Souvenir of the Carlton Football Club says the Blues lost this match.
.* "Orange and Blue" is possibly Carlton player and administrator Tom P. Power

July 08
No details
Possibly resumed the match against Royal Park.

July 15
Carlton played Williamstown at Carlton (Royal Park?)
The game was to commence at 2.30pm
Carlton team; (24 named)
Adamson, Armytage, Bowen, Byrne, Clark, Duncan, Fargher, Gaggin, T. Gorman, W. Gorman, Green, Guy, Harper, Hillsden, Horan, James, McFarland, J. McHarg, O'Brien, Phillips, Power, Webb, Williams, W. Williams.
Carlton won; 2-0
Goals; J. McHarg, O'Brien
Players mentioned; (6) Byrne, Guy, T. Gorman, W. Gorman, all played exceedingly well, J. McHarg, O'Brien.
This is the first mention found so far of Carlton players who were playing.

July 22
Carlton played the Warehousemen's club at their ground at St.Kilda.
"A very good afternoon's sport was the result, although neither side succeeded in getting a goal." (Age July 24 p5)
Carlton team; (25 named)
Adamson, Bowen, Byrne, Chadwick, Clark, Duncan, T. Gorman, J. Gorman, Guy, Hillsden, Hayer, James Horan, James, A. McFarland, A. McHarg, J. McHarg, O'Brien, Power, Phillips, Richardson, Robertson, Robertson, Mick Webb, J. Williams, W. Williams.
Saturday's Herald (p2) mentioned a team squad of 25, with Armytage, Green, W. Grey, Harper in team squad, no Bowen, Guy, Hayer, and one of the Robertsons mentioned.
Match drawn. 0-0
Players mentioned; T. Gorman, Chadwick, Byrne, Guy, Horan,
1879 Map
Warehouseman's Ground, now the Albert Cricket Ground. Carlton's first known match was where the Alfred Hospital stands.
Also Wesley College is shown, where future Carlton player Henry F. Rix would almost singlehandedly clear the scrub for the football/cricket ground fronting Brighton now St.Kilda Road.
Carlton would play Prahran on the Wesley ground in the 1880's

July 22


"There is every probability that the Geelong Football Club, which has so long been the pride of Geelong, will be broken up, owing to the very meagre attendance at the usually weekly practice.
For the last few weeks some half-dozen of the best players have made a point of going to the ground, but have always been disappointed.
The Geelong Advertiser asks - "What are the committee and their hitherto active secretary thinking of?"
Australasian (p4)

July 29
Carlton (Union) played Emerald Hill at Emerald Hill.
Result; Carlton 0 - 1 (considered a draw)
The Leader August 05 (p2) mentioned "Carlton."

August 05
Carlton played Royal Park at Carlton ( Royal Park?)
The return match
The game was scheduled to start at 2.30pm.
Carlton team; (27 named)
Adamson, Bowen, Buchan, Clark, Duncan, Finlay, Gaggin, Gordon, Gorman, Gorman, Guy, Harper, Hewitt, Hillsden, Horan, Ick, James, McHarg, McHarg, McFarland, O'Brien, Phillips, Power, Richardson, Webb, Williams, Williams
Herald; "resulted in favour of the former." (Carlton)
Bells Life (August 12) described it as a Carlton victory, 1 - 0
Result; Carlton 1-0 (considered a draw)
Goal; W. Gorman
Players mentioned; T. Gorman, W. Gorman, Guy, Hillsden, Duncan, O'Brien.

August 12
Carlton played a practice match in Princes Park at 2.30pm, in preparation of the Challenge Cup match.

August 19


University now are the holders the Cup after upsetting Melbourne who fielded a very weak team.
Melbourne were supposed to play Geelong for the Cup this week but they under estimated University.
The scholars have refused to play Geelong and opted to play South Yarra who have already played three other Cup games.
Bells (p4) published a Challenge Cup fixture for the remainder of the season.
"We are requested to state by the Athletic Sports Committee that the Cup engagements are as follows:-
19th August, Holders v SouthYarra.
26th August, Holders v Geelong.
2nd. September, Holders v Carlton.
9th. September, Holders v Melbourne.
And whatever club wins the contest to-day are bound by the above programme."

August 19
Carlton played Emerald Hill at Emerald Hill.
Carlton team; (23 named)
Adamson, Bowen, Buchan, Chadwick, Clark, Duncan, Finlay, Gaggin, Gorman, Gorman, Guy, Harper, Hillsden, Horan, James, McFarland, J. McHarg, O'Brien, Phillips, Richardson, Robertson, Webb, Williams
Match drawn; 0-0

August 26
Carlton played Warehousemen at 2.30pm. at Phoenix Park, near the cemetery, The Age said Princes Park.
Monday's Age and the Geelong Advertiser said the match was at Royal Park.
Mondays Herald said Carlton played Warehousemen and Royal Park combined.
Their team contained some familiar names, J. E. Clarke, Forrester, Armytage, Ievers (a name associated with the administration of Carlton), G. Waugh. Marshall, Kennedy, McCarthy.
Carlton team; (25 named)
Adamson, Bowen, Buchan, Byrne, Chadwick, Clark, Duncan, Finlay, William W. Gaggin, Gorman, Gorman, Guy, Hillsden, Horan, Ick, James, McFarland, McHarg, O'Brien, Phillips, Power, Richardson, Mick Webb, Williams, Williams.
Carlton won; 2-1
Goals; O'Brien, Duncan.
Players mentioned; Bowen, O'Brien, Duncan, Guy.

September 02
Carlton were fixtured to play the Holders of the Cup.
The Sports Committee recommended that University should play Carlton for the Cup.
University decided tp play a return match against South Yarra on August 26 instead. They renegged to play Carlton and lost within an hour to the Yarraites.
Several of the University's best men refused to play for their club.
Now the new holders of the Cup, South Yarra, have decided not to be bound by the arrangements put in place for Univeristy and the fixture, and have arranged to play Royal Park today.
The Athletic Sports Commission intends to alter the Cup rules, to compel clubs to follow the arranged matches, or be debarred for playing for the Cup. (Australasian August 25 p4)

September 09
Carlton played South Yarra for the Challenge Cup at South Yarra.
The South Yarra ground was on the green at the rear of the English Church.
Possibly the Anglican Christ Church on the corner of Punt and Toorak Roads.
The report said that Carlton wore an orange cap which made them easy for the spectators to spot from the motley colours worn by the South Yarra team.
The Blues kicking was as good as the Yarraites, but the opposition's dodging and quick turning was better.
After half an hour's play South Yarra's goal was allowed after the Blues claimed it was touched.
Budd of South Yarra scored the second and winning goal.
Chadwick captained Carlton.
Umpires; G.M. Nichols, Fitzgerald.
Carlton lost; 0-2
The Blues only played one game for the Cup in 1865 against South Yarra and were defeated. 0-2.
Play lasted from 2.45pm until 5.20pm when H. H. Budd of South Yarra kicked the winning goal,
"It was a magnificent place kick from 50 yards in front of the posts".

I was there when H. H. Budd (South Yarra) made that famous place kick (70 yards if it was an inch) that defeated Carlton the first time the latter had played with the oval ball, and a little one, too, at that.
The Footballer 1876.

The Argus, Monday 11 September 1865 (page 5), refers to the match-
The football contest Saturday afternoon for The Athletic Sports Committee's Challenge Cup was between the South Yarra and Carlton Clubs, who met on the ground of the former club.
South Yarra, who were the holders of the cup, succeeded in winning the match by obtaining two goals, one of which was kicked by Budd, and the other by Greene. These were the only goals got during the afternoon. O'Mullane was captain of the winning, and Chadwick of the losing side.
The Carlton Club ascribe their defeat to the fact that they were obliged to play with the oval, or Rugby ball, while they had always been accustomed to the round ball; and they complain that their opponents would not allow the round ball to introduced even after they had won the first goal.
The South Yarra Club have now won the cup twice, being the only club standing in that position. If they win it a third time, they will, according to the rules, be entitled to retain possession of the trophy.

September 15 Friday
The Argus, p8
GENERAL MEETING CARLTON FOOTBALL CLUB will be held at the Rifle Brigade Hotel, Carlton, at half past 7pm. This Evening. B. James Hon Sec.

The following is from the Centenary Souvenir of the Carlton Football Club, published 1934.
1865 September 15
Second annual meeting of the Carlton Football Club.
President; James Linacre.
Vice president; John Walls.
Secretary; Ben James.
Captain T. S. Marshall.
Committee; Bruce, McLeach, Waugh, McFarland.

September 16
The Argus;
"A general meeting of members of the Carlton Football Club was held last evening at the Rifle Brigade Hotel, Carlton, for the purpose of winding up the affairs of the club for the past season, and also to make arrangements for a dinner to be held next Wednesday.
Mr. R. McFarland was in the chair. The secretary, Mr. B. James, read a report of the doings of the past season, showing that the club had only one match out of ten, and had a balance in hand at the present time.
After a vote of thanks to the office-bearers for the past season, the meeting adjourned."

September 16;
The Age;
"A meeting of the Carlton Football Club was held at the Rifle Brigade Hotel, Lygon-street, last evening, for the purpose of receiving the committee's report of the past season, and for disposing of other business in connection of the club. Mr. McFarland occupied the chair.
The secretary, Mr. B. James, read the report, from which it appeared that the members had lost one match out of nine, and had a small balance in hand.
The report was unanimously adopted, and after a vote of thanks had been passed to the chairman, and to the office bearers, the meeting broke up."

Blueseum, so far, has found that Carlton played nine matches including the Challenge Cup match against South Yarra.
The Blues played;
Melbourne Grammar, Warehousemen, Royal Park, Williamstown, Warehousemen, Emerald Hill, Royal Park, Emerald Hill, South Yarra.

September 16
Melbourne played South Yarra for the Challenge Cup.
Melbourne were short of players and two Carlton men played for Melbourne, Gorman and Toohey.
South Yarra were in the same predicament and Carlton's Chadwick played for the Yarra-ites. (Bells Life Sept 23 p2)

1865. Premiers. South Yarra, 2. Melbourne, 3. University

Challenge Cup games for 1865.
May 24: Melbourne vs Geelong, Melbourne won 2-1
June 17: Melbourne vs South Yarra, Drawn 0-1
July 15: Melbourne vs Royal Park, Drawn 0-1
July 20 & 23: Melbourne vs South Yarra, Drawn 1-1
August 5: Melbourne vs University, University won 2-1, University now Holders of the Cup.
August 19 & 26: University vs South Yarra, South Yarra won 2-1, South Yarra now Holders of the Cup.
September 2: South vs Royal Park, Drawn 1-0
September 9: South Yarra vs Carlton, South Yarra won 2-0.
September 16: South Yarra vs Melbourne, Melbourne won 2-0, Melbourne now Holders of the Cup.

The Carlton Story, Hugh Buggy and Harry Bell. Pages 8,9. 259.
Mullin's Footballers Australian Almanac of 1951 Page 66.
Everything You Wanted To Know About Australian Rules Football But Couldn't Be Bothered Asking. Graeme Atkinson. p205.
Bells Life in Victoria.
The Centenary Souvenir of the Carlton Football Club. p5.
The Argus 1865 editions.
The Australasian 1865 editions.
The Age, 1865 editions.
The Herald, 1865 editions.
The Leader, 1865 editions

Pre VFL Players | The Guernsey | Pre VFL Venues | Pre VFL Captains | Pre VFL Vice Captains | Formation of the Club
Melbourne Rules Years: 1864 |Challenge Cup Competition: 1865 | 1866 | 1867 | 1868 | 1869 | 1870 | 1871 | 1872 | 1873 | 1874 | 1875 | 1876
VFA Years: 1877 | 1878 | 1879 | 1880 | 1881 | 1882 | 1883 | 1884 | 1885 | 1886 | 1887 | 1888 | 1889 | 1890 | 1891 | 1892 | 1893 | 1894 | 1895 | 1896

Contributors to this page: blueycarlton , Jarusa , molsey and admin .
Page last modified on Friday 02 of February, 2024 11:43:34 AEDT by blueycarlton.

Google Search

Random Image

1907 Semi Final v St.Kilda
1953 B. Chitty, F. Anderson, H. Dunn, J. Francis old players match v NM SG 29 April p16

Online Users

191 online users