| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Len Morrison | 1898 - 1902 | Fremantle, WA / North Melbourne, VFA / Albion United |
| Tommy O'Day | 1898 | Imperials, WA / Nth Melbourne VFA / Nth Melb. Juniors |
| Gerald O'Dwyer | 1900 | Fremantle, WA / Melbourne VFA / Napier Imperials |
| Bill Goddard | 1910 | South Melbourne / North Fremantle, WA |
| Jack Wells | 1910 - 1914 | St Kilda / Midland Junction, WA / Kalgoorlie, WA |
| Ron 'Socks' Cooper | 1932 - 1942 | Cottesloe / Albany, WA |
| Ken Hunter | 1981 - 1989 | Claremont / Dalkeith Juniors, WA |
| Peter Bosustow | 1981 - 1983 | Perth / East Victoria Park, WA |
| Warren Ralph | 1984 - 1986 | Claremont / Floreat, WA |
| Wayne Blackwell | 1984 - 1990 | Claremont / North Beach Juniors / Karrinyup Saints, WA, Hale School WA |
| Rhett Baynes | 1985 - 1986 | Perth / East Victoria Park, WA |
| Michael Aitken | 1985 - 1986 | Claremont / Floreat, WA |
| Grant Povey | 1989 - 1990 | Claremont / Scotch College, WA |
| Stephen Edgar | 1990 - 1991 | East Fremantle / Melville FC, WA |
| Richard Hadley | 2008 - 2010 | East Fremantle/ Willetton, WA |
| Steven Browne | 2008 - 2010 | West Perth / Whitfords Junior FC, WA |
| Dennis Armfield | 2008 - 2017 | Swan Districts / Originally from Eastern Hills Hawks, Kalamunda WA |
| David Ellard | 2008 - 2015 | Swan Districts / Originally from Guildford Grammar, WA |
| Chris Yarran | 2009 - 2015 | Swan Districts / Midvale Junior FC, WA |
| Kane Lucas | 2010 - 2014 | East Fremantle / Trinity College, WA |
| Simon White | 2010 - 2017 | Subiaco / Carine, WA |
| Joshua Donaldson* | 2010 | West Perth / Ocean Ridge, WA |
| Josh Bootsma | 2012 - 2014 | South Fremantle / South Coogee FC, / Albany WA |
| Clem Smith | 2015 - 2016 | Perth / Thornlie JFC WA |
| Jesse Glass-McCasker * | 2016 - 2018 | Swan Districts / Bassendean JFC / Guildford Grammar WA |
| Jarrod Pickett | 2017 - 2019 | South Fremantle / Jandakot JFC WA |
| Rhys Palmer | 2017 | East Fremantle / Bullcreek Leeming JFC WA |
| Jarrod Garlett | 2018 - 2019 | South Fremantle / Gold Coast Suns / Bibra Lake JFC WA |
| Alex Fasolo | 2019 | East Fremantle / Collingwood / Trinity College, East Perth, Attadale WA |
| Josh Deluca | 2019 | Subiaco / Peel Thunder / Fremantle Dockers / Subiaco / Sorrento Duncraig JFC |
| Jesse Motlop | 2022 - ? | South Fremantle / South Coogee JFC / ​Aquinas College (WA). |
| Blake Acres | 2023 - ? | Fremantle / St Kilda / West Perth / Edgewater-Woodvale JFC (WA). |
NB * denotes player is yet to, or did not play a senior game for Carlton.