1938 - Fred Ayers
1939 - Bernie Bignell
1940 - Albert 'Mick' Price tied with Arthur Sanger
1943 - Herb Turner
1944 - Bert Butler
1945 - Dan Beauvais
1946 - Fred Hale
1947 - Fred Hale
1948 - Alan Thynne
1949 - Ken Shaw
1950 - Doug Guy
1951 - Ken Aitken
1952 - Harry Dern
1953 - Peter Webster
1954 - A. Max Thomas
1955 - Barry Beitzel
1956 - Brian Buckley
1957 - Laurie Rogers
1958 - Bill Armstrong
1959 - Jack Sullivan
1960 - Jack Sullivan
1961 - Jim Carroll
1962 - John Reilly
1963 - Barry Schmidt
1964 - Roger Hoggett
1965 - Dennis O'Sullivan
1966 - Paul Constance
1967 - Ron Auchettl
1968 - Rodney Wilkinson
1969 - Barry Armstrong
1970 - Mark Amos
1971 - Peter Fyffe
1972 - Peter Fyffe
1973 - Eric Pascoe
1974 - Alan Mangels
1975 - Bryan Quirk
1976 - Trevor Fletcher
1977 - Ian Zeunert
1978 - Alex Marcou
1979 - Warren 'Wow' Jones
1980 - Graeme Whitnall
1981 - Trevor Keogh
1982 - Spiro Kourkoumelis
1983 - Brendan Hartney
1984 - Brendan Hartney
1985 - Brad Shine
1986 - Rhett Baynes
1987 - Jim Buckley
1988 - Bernie Evans
1989 - Andrew Phillips
1990 - Andrew Phillips
1991 - Michael James
1992 - Anthony Koutoufides
1993 - Mark Athorn - Votes
1994 - Matthew Allan
1995 - Ben Harrison
1996 - Adrian Gleeson
1997 - Adrian Gleeson
1998 - John Hynes
1999 - Simon Fletcher
2000 - Jordan Doering
2001 - Andrew Merrington tied with Trent Sporn
2002 - Tim Fleming
Between 2000 and 2002 Carlton Reserves played in the VFL as Carlton VFL and from 2003 Carlton Reserves played with the Northern Blues in the VFL. Best and Fairest Awards from 2002 to 2019 are provided here.
From 2021 Carlton again fielded a side in the new VFL that also included sides from New South Wales and Queensland
2021 - Ben Crocker
2022 - Paddy Dow
2023 - Jaxon Binns
1939 - Bernie Bignell
1940 - Albert 'Mick' Price tied with Arthur Sanger
1943 - Herb Turner
1944 - Bert Butler
1945 - Dan Beauvais
1946 - Fred Hale
1947 - Fred Hale
1948 - Alan Thynne
1949 - Ken Shaw
1950 - Doug Guy
1951 - Ken Aitken
1952 - Harry Dern
1953 - Peter Webster
1954 - A. Max Thomas
1955 - Barry Beitzel
1956 - Brian Buckley
1957 - Laurie Rogers
1958 - Bill Armstrong
1959 - Jack Sullivan
1960 - Jack Sullivan
1961 - Jim Carroll
1962 - John Reilly
1963 - Barry Schmidt
1964 - Roger Hoggett
1965 - Dennis O'Sullivan
1966 - Paul Constance
1967 - Ron Auchettl
1968 - Rodney Wilkinson
1969 - Barry Armstrong
1970 - Mark Amos
1971 - Peter Fyffe
1972 - Peter Fyffe
1973 - Eric Pascoe
1974 - Alan Mangels
1975 - Bryan Quirk
1976 - Trevor Fletcher
1977 - Ian Zeunert
1978 - Alex Marcou
1979 - Warren 'Wow' Jones
1980 - Graeme Whitnall
1981 - Trevor Keogh
1982 - Spiro Kourkoumelis
1983 - Brendan Hartney
1984 - Brendan Hartney
1985 - Brad Shine
1986 - Rhett Baynes
1987 - Jim Buckley
1988 - Bernie Evans
1989 - Andrew Phillips
1990 - Andrew Phillips
1991 - Michael James
1992 - Anthony Koutoufides
1993 - Mark Athorn - Votes
1994 - Matthew Allan
1995 - Ben Harrison
1996 - Adrian Gleeson
1997 - Adrian Gleeson
1998 - John Hynes
1999 - Simon Fletcher
2000 - Jordan Doering
2001 - Andrew Merrington tied with Trent Sporn
2002 - Tim Fleming
Between 2000 and 2002 Carlton Reserves played in the VFL as Carlton VFL and from 2003 Carlton Reserves played with the Northern Blues in the VFL. Best and Fairest Awards from 2002 to 2019 are provided here.
From 2021 Carlton again fielded a side in the new VFL that also included sides from New South Wales and Queensland
2021 - Ben Crocker
2022 - Paddy Dow
2023 - Jaxon Binns