| Player | Era | Recruited From |
| Jimmy Aitken | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA |
| Ernie Walton | 1897 - 1904 | Carlton VFA / Austral * / Rainbow |
| Bill Ahern | 1897 | Preston |
| Bob Armstrong | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA / Nth Melbourne Juniors |
| Tom Blake | 1897 | Carlton VFA / St Kilda VFA / St Kilda Royals |
| Otto Buck | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Royal Park Crescent |
| Bob Cameron | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Brunswick College |
| Bill Casey | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Brunswick College |
| Henry Dunne | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA / Austral * |
| Brook Hannah | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Fitzroy VFA / Carlton Reserves / Melbourne University |
| Ted Heffernan | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Fitzroy Juniors |
| George Johnston | 1897 | Albert Park |
| Henry McPetrie | 1897 | Richmond City / St Kilda VFA / West Beach |
| Wally Ocock | 1897 - 1901 | Carlton VFA / Albion United |
| John "Joe" Paton | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Albion United |
| Jack Reekie | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA / Albion United |
| Bill Weir | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA / Fitzroy VFA / Fitzroy Juniors |
| Bill Woodhouse | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA / Broken Hill / St Kilda VFA / Melbourne Grammar |
| Sam Chapman | 1897 - 1898 | Fitzroy VFA / Sth Melb. VFA / St Kilda VFA / Scotch College |
| Harry Gyles | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Richmond Juniors |
| Harry Howard | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Fitzroy Juniors |
| Peter Williams | 1897 - 1901 | Carlton VFA / Ballarat |
| Chic Breese | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA / Williamstown / Ascot Vale / Wesley College |
| Jim Caffery | 1897 | Carlton District / Rainbow |
| Jim Lyons | 1897 - 1898 | Parkville |
| Bobby Walsh | 1897 - 1902 | Carlton VFA / Footscray VFA |
| Jack Frost | 1897 | Carlton VFA / Nth Williamstown Juniors |
| Jack Roberts | 1897 - 1899 | Carlton VFA / North Park * |
| Oscar Manchester | 1897 - 1898 | Brunswick / Rainbow / University |
| Bill Patterson | 1897 - 1898 | Carlton VFA / Rainbow |
| Herbie Lowenthal | 1897 | Austral * |
| Jim Goonan | 1897 | No record of original club |
| Billy Arnott | 1897 | Collingwood VFA / Richmond City |
| Len Morrison | 1898 - 1902 | Fremantle / Nth Melbourne / Albion United |
| Tommy O'Day | 1898 | Imperials WA / Nth Melbourne VFA / Nth Melbourne Juniors |
| Bill Sharkey | 1898 - 1901 | Fitzroy Juniors / Carlton Juniors |
| Charlie Curtis | 1898 - 1900 | Cardigan * |
| Dan Pender | 1898 | Wellington Juniors (Geelong Juniors) / Footscray VFA / Marylebone * |
| Tommy Kinman | 1898 | West Melb. / Nth Melb. VFA / Cumberland * |
| Herman Dohrmann | 1898 - 1899 | Perth / Collingwood VFA / Carlton Juniors / Nth Melb. VFA |
| Bill Churchyard | 1898 - 1899 | Melbourne Juniors / Royal Park Crescent / Albion United |
| Dick Stewart | 1898, 1900 | Carlton VFA / Carlton Juniors |
| Jim Balharry | 1898 | Carlton VFA / North Williamstown Juniors |
| Pat Considine | 1898 | West Melbourne Juniors / British Star * |
| Jack Douglas | 1898 | Cardigan * / Albion United |
| Henry Allender | 1899 | Collingwood Juniors |
| George Cowell | 1899 | Collingwood |
| Alf Hearnden | 1899 | Carlton VFA / Fitzroy VFA / Fitzroy Crescent |
| Bill McNamara | 1899 - 1904 | Brunswick |
| Henry McShane | 1899 - 1904 | Geelong / Geelong VFA / Marylebone * |
| Billy Monagle | 1899 | Port Melbourne |
| Will Stuckey | 1899 - 1900 | West Melbourne VFA / Nth Melbourne VFA / Essendon VFA / Essendon Districts |
| Bob Bird | 1899 - 1900 | Collingwood / Collingwood Juniors |
| Dan Lanigan | 1899 | Melbourne / Collingwood / Collingwood VFA / Collingwood Juniors |
| Arthur Thompson | 1899 - 1901 | Williamstown / Carlton VFA / Williamstown / Nth Williamstown |
| Artie McSpeerin | 1899 | Phoenix * |
| Harry Lewis | 1899 | Montague Juniors * |
| Dick Gorsuch | 1899 | Princes Hill |
| Jack Gilbert | 1899 - 1900 | Fitzroy Crescent |
| Victor Rapp | 1899 | North Melbourne Juniors |
| Fred Elliott | 1900 - 1911 | Melbourne / Cardigan * |
| Gerald O'Dwyer | 1900 | Fremantle / Melbourne VFA / Napier Imperials * |
| Wally Powell | 1900 - 1902 | No record of original club |
| Joe Sullivan | 1900 - 1903 | Rutherglen / Port Melbourne / Collingwood VFA / Collingwood Imperials |
| Peter Campbell | 1900 | Parkville Juniors |
| Charlie Ross | 1900 - 1904 | Brunswick |
| Charlie Oliver | 1900 | Carlton Imperials / Melbourne Juniors |
| Ned Bennett | 1900 | Montague Juniors * |
| Jim Matthews | 1900 | Celtic * |
| Charlie Maplestone | 1900 - 1902 | Parkville |
| Harold Daniel | 1901 | Port Melbourne |
| Dick Hart | 1901 - 1902 | Carlton Juniors / Carlton Imperials |
| Jim Loriot | 1901 | Collingwood Juniors |
| Paddy Noonan | 1901 - 1902 | Fitzroy / Fitzroy VFA / Albion United / Nth Melb. VFA |
| Harry Pye | 1901 - 1902 | St Luke's |
| Charles Raff | 1901 | Carlton Juniors / St Kilda / Parkville |
| Jack Gardiner | 1901 - 1902 | No record of original club |
| Jimmy Robinson | 1901 | Stanley United |
| Charlie Stewart | 1901 | Essendon District |
| Rhoda McDonald | 1901 | Collingwood / Sth Adelaide / Collingwood / Collingwood Juniors |
| Harry Powell | 1901 - 1902 | Fitzroy Crescent |
| Charlie Schunke | 1901 | Fitzroy Crescent / Carlton Imperials / Phoenix * |
| George McGann | 1901 | Coburg Juniors |
| Simon Roberts | 1901 | Coburg Juniors |
| Bill Dodds | 1901 | Albion United |
| Jack Todd | 1901 - 1902 | Leopold / Carlton Juniors / Prahran |
| Joe McShane | 1902 - 1904 | Geelong / Geelong VFA / Sth Melbourne / Geelong VFA / Marylebone * /Criterion Juniors * |
| George Wickens | 1902 | Carlton Imperials |
| Arthur Ryan | 1904 | St Ignatius * |
| Fred Scott | 1902 - 1904 | Essendon / Essendon VFA / Essendon District / Parkville / Scotch College |
| Gordon Ross | 1902 - 1903 | Fitzroy / Melbourne University |
| Jim Opie | 1902 - 1905 | Melbourne University / Prahran / St Kilda / Sandhurst Juniors |
| Barney Lazarus | 1902 | Carlton Juniors / Princes Hill |
| Jim Martin | 1902 | Carlton Juniors |
| Fred Webber | 1902 - 1904 | Carlton College |
| George Topping | 1902 - 1916 | Carlton Juniors |
| Andrew Dougall | 1902 | Melbourne University |
| Charlie O'Connor | 1902 - 1904 | Brunswick CYMS |
| Wal McKenzie | 1902 | Carlton Imperials |
| Pat McNulty | 1902 | Carlton Imperials |
| Jim Flynn | 1903 - 1910 | Geelong / Benalla District / Collingwood VFA / Canterbury |
| Arthur Ford | 1903 - 1912 | Boulder City, WA / West Perth / Carlton / Essendon Town VFA |
| Billy Leeds | 1903 - 1905 | Brunswick |
| Albert Trim | 1903 - 1904 | Sth Melbourne / Beechworth |
| Mick Grace | 1903 - 1907 | Fitzroy / Fitzroy VFA / Fitzroy Juniors |
| Frank Hince | 1903 - 1906 | Fitzroy / Fitzroy Crescent |
| Matt Crowe | 1903 - 1904 | Carlton Juniors |
| Alex Prentice | 1903 | Port Melbourne Rovers |
| Jim Cullen | 1904 | Leopold / Melbourne / Sth Melb. Juniors / Sth Melb. / Essendon / Port Melb. |
| Ted Kennedy | 1904 - 1909 | Essendon / Nth Melb. Juniors / St Jude's Carlton |
| Henry Newbound | 1904 - 1905 | Collingwood Juniors / Blenheim / Collingwood / Collingwood Juniors |
| Percy Pitt | 1904 | Essendon Town VFA |
| Rupe Bradley | 1904 - 1905 | Fitzroy Juniors |
| Bob Boyle | 1904 - 1906 | Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Jimmy Gaynor | 1904 | Carlton District |
| Albert Gourlay | 1904 | Melbourne / West Melbourne VFA |
| Charlie Hammond | 1905 - 1918 | Northcote / Nth Melbourne VFA / Carlton / Northcote |
| Jim Kennedy | 1905 - 1907 | Brighton Juniors / Essendon / Parkville |
| Bert Parke | 1905, 1913 | Melbourne / Carlton / University High School |
| Edgar Yeomans | 1905 | Northcote |
| Rod McGregor | 1905 - 1920 | Essendon Town VFA / Brougham Street Methodists / Daylesford |
| Alf Sharp | 1905 | Fitzroy / Fitzroy Juniors |
| Les Abbott | 1905 | Collingwood / Collingwood Juniors / Brunswick |
| Frank Caine | 1905 - 1909 | Rose of Northcote / Minyip |
| Fred Hewitt | 1905 | Collingwood Juniors |
| Alby Ingleman | 1905 - 1908 | Brunswick Juniors |
| Martin Gotz | 1906 - 1913 | East Fremantle / Port Melbourne |
| Bill Grant | 1906 | Bulla |
| Alex Lang | 1906 - 1917 | Parkville Presbyterians |
| Doug Gillespie | 1906 - 1912 | Parkville |
| Alex Johnston | 1906 | Nth Melbourne VFA / Lancefield |
| Dick Harris | 1906 - 1911 | Essendon / Nth Melbourne VFA / Caulfield |
| Jack Grant | 1906 | Carlton Juniors |
| Jack Hammond | 1906 | Northcote VFA |
| Les Beck | 1906 - 1909 | Carlton Juniors |
| Albert Bickford | 1906 - 1907 | Essendon VFA |
| Harvey Gibson | 1906 | Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Ike Little | 1906 | Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Frank H Williams | 1907 - 1908 | Royal Park Juniors |
| Vin Gardiner | 1907 - 1917 | Melbourne |
| Dave Gillespie | 1907 - 1909 | Royal Park |
| Wally Koochew | 1908 | Brunswick VFA |
| Bill Laver | 1908 | Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Alex Barningham | 1909 - 1915 | Carlton District |
| Jack Baquie | 1909 - 1913 | Seymour / Melbourne / Brunswick VFA |
| Jim Neylan | 1909 - 1910 | Fitzroy / West Melbourne VFA |
| Andy O'Donnell | 1910 - 1913 | Carlton District |
| Percy Sheehan | 1910 | Fitzroy / Caulfield Juniors |
| Jack Bristow | 1910 | Carlton Juniors / Lancefield |
| John 'Jack' Massey | 1910 | Carlton Juniors |
| Ned Bowen | 1911 - 1912 | Port Melbourne Juniors |
| Tom Hanson | 1911 | Grosvenor |
| Roy Johnson | 1911 - 1912 | Carlton District |
| Les Rowe | 1911 | Carlton District / Melbourne High School |
| Herbert Cock | 1911 | Collingwood / Collingwood District |
| Billy Dick | 1911 - 1918 | Fitzroy / Brighton / East Brunswick |
| Jim Stewart | 1912 | St Kilda / Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Frank Triplett | 1912 - 1915 | Carlton District / Brunswick VFA |
| Harry Haughton | 1912 - 1919 | Northcote VFA |
| Bill Johnson | 1912 | Queensland / Essendon / West Melbourne VFA / Castlemaine |
| Alf Williamson | 1912 - 1914 | Teachers Training College * |
| Herman Bartlett | 1912 | Fitzroy / Northcote VFA |
| Richard Moran | 1912 - 1913 | Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Paddy Mills | 1912 - 1913 | South Bendigo / Melbourne / Northcote VFA |
| Dave Earsman | 1913 | Fitzroy / Fitzroy Juniors / Northcote VFA |
| Chris Cameron | 1913 | Beverley * / Rushworth Tigers |
| Willie Rogers | 1913 | Carlton District / Wonthaggi |
| Justin McCarthy | 1913 - 1914 | Nth Melbourne Juniors |
| Harry Curtis | 1913 | Wesley Collegians / Carlton College |
| Athol Sharp | 1913 - 1920 | Moonee Ponds |
| Harold G. Evans | 1913 | Carlton District |
| Frank Hanna | 1913 - 1914 | Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Wally Don | 1913 | Teacher's Training College * |
| Mort Keily | 1914 - 1921 | Brunswick Juniors |
| Jim Willis | 1914, 1918 | Brunswick / Tramways * / Northcote |
| George Calwell | 1914 - 1916 | Clifton's Rope Works * |
| Jack Lowe | 1914 | Collingwood / Seymour |
| Joe Andrew | 1914 | Carlton District / Brunswick / Collingwood |
| Harold G. Evans | 1913 | Carlton District |
| Frank Hanna | 1913 - 1914 | Nth Melbourne VFA |
| Wally Don | 1913 | Teacher's Training College * |
| Bill Hore | 1915 - 1919 | Melbourne / St Kilda / Northcote / Carlton District / Police * |
| Vic Gordon | 1915 | Melbourne / St Kilda / Hawthorn VFA |
| George Muir | 1915, 1918 | Northcote VFA / Bendigo |
| George White | 1916 - 1919 | Coburg VFA |
| Charlie Canet | 1916 - 1921 | Brunswick Juniors |
| Robert White | 1916 | Carlton District |
| Frank Rigaldi | 1916 | Carlton District / Williamstown VFA |
| Lyle Downs | 1917 - 1921 | Clifton Hill Juniors |
| Willis Hardy | 1917 | Carlton District |
| Dave Crone | 1917 - 1920 | Fitzroy / Sth Ballarat / Donald |
| Horrie White | 1917 - 1918 | Brunswick Tramways |
| Ern Cowley | 1918 - 1919 | Brunswick |
| Fred Johnson | 1918 - 1924 | Tramways * |
| Percy Jackson | 1918 | St Kilda / Sth Melbourne / Port Melbourne Juniors |
| Harry Furnell | 1918 - 1919 | University / Geelong Grammar |
| Jack Woolley | 1918 - 1919 | Hawthorn VFA / Melbourne / Essendon / South Yarra / Northcote VFA / Preston VFA |
| Jim Howe | 1918 - 1919 | Teacher's Training College * |
| Bill Clohesy | 1918 | Carlton Juniors |
| Frank Mercovich | 1918 - 1920 | Carlton District |
| Bert Graf | 1919 | Williamstown Juniors / Melbourne District |
| Newton Chandler | 1919 - 1924 | Brunswick / Porepunkah |
| Morrie Ewans | 1919 - 1921 | Brunswick Juniors |
| Jack Scobie | 1919 | East Fremantle / Sth Melbourne / Rose of Northcote |
| Joe Prince | 1919 | Sth Melbourne / St Kilda / Preston VFA / Rose of Northcote / Avenel |
| Vic Truman | 1920 | Carlton District |
| Dick Wittmann | 1920 - 1921 | Carlton District |
| Clarrie Clowe | 1920 - 1921 | Brunswick |
| Clarrie Calwell | 1920 | Army * / Williamstown Juniors / Clifton's Rope Works * / Camberwell |
| Wally Raleigh | 1920 - 1921 | Collingwood / Fitzroy Juniors |
| Billy Blackman | 1920 - 1924 | Brunswick Juniors |
| Alf Key | 1920 | Carlton District |
| Edric Bickford | 1920 - 1922 | Essendon / Brougham Street Methodists * |
| Johnny Downs | 1920 | Fitzroy / Fitzroy District |
| Vern Wright | 1920, 1922 | Carlton District / Brunswick / Fitzroy Reserves |
| Alex Duncan | 1921 - 1930 | Stratford / Carlton / Romsey / Coburg |
| Harry Bell | 1921 - 1927 | Carlton District / Preston VFA |
| Jim Watson | 1921 - 1929 | Carlton District |
| Harry Toole | 1921 - 1925 | Carlton District |
| Dan Whannell | 1921 - 1923 | Carlton District |
| Frank Murphy | 1921 | Carlton District |
| George Bolt | 1922 - 1923 | Brunswick |
| Alec Farrow | 1922 - 1923 | Melbourne / Army * / Carlton District |
| Jimmy Goonan | 1922 - 1927 | Brunswick |
| Johnny Davies | 1922 - 1924 | Carlton District |
| Joe Russell | 1922 - 1925 | North Melbourne VFA |
| Graham Kemp | 1922 | Carlton District |
| Harold Credlin | 1922 - 1925 | Carlton Juniors / Inglewood |
| Rowley Faust | 1923 | Brunswick |
| Ray Brew | 1923 - 1931 | St Kevin's (Toorak) / West Melbourne CYMS / Newman College (Carlton) |
| Ernie Martin | 1923, 1925 | Essendon Reserves / Carlton District |
| Les Husband | 1923 - 1924 | Collingwood District / Box Hill / Trinity Grammarians (Kew) |
| Pat Kennedy | 1923 - 1925 | University Blacks / Newman College (Carlton) / Sth Melbourne CYMS / Cobram |
| Harold Carter | 1924 - 1928 | Fitzroy / South Bendigo |
| Jimmy Robertson | 1924, 1926 | Carlton District |
| Norm Sexton | 1924 | Coburg |
| Harvey Dunn | 1924 - 1929 | Carlton District |
| Ted Brewis | 1925 - 1928 | Maffra / Maryborough / Camberwell / Preston VFA |
| Victor Davis | 1925 - 1926 | Preston VFA |
| Billy Stone | 1925 | Coburg / Camberwell |
| Jack Vale | 1925 | Carlton District |
| Jack Way | 1925, 1927 | Carlton District / Brunswick Juniors |
| Carl Keller | 1925 | Fitzroy / Preston VFA / South Preston Rovers |
| Charlie McSwain | 1925 - 1930 | Preston VFA / Merebin |
| Jack Cahill | 1925 | Carlton District / Williamstown VFA / Brunswick VFA |
| Frank Donoghue | 1925 - 1928 | Rosedale / University Blues |
| Maurie Connell | 1925 - 1929 | Uni. Blues / Brighton / Newman College / Sth Melb. / Yarrawonga / St Pat's Ballarat |
| George Robbins | 1925, 1929 | St Kilda / Rutherglen / Wesley College (Melb.) |
| Harry McPherson | 1925 - 1926 | Fire Brigade * / Essendon Reserves / Essendon Districts / Prahran VFA |
| Joe Kelly | 1926 - 1934 | Thornbury CYMS / Old Xaverians (Kew) |
| Fred Mutch | 1926 | Collingwood |
| Norm Collins | 1926 - 1931 | Fitzroy / Fitzroy Juniors |
| George Styles | 1926 - 1927 | Port Melbourne VFA |
| Bill Manger | 1926 | Essendon |
| Fred Gilby | 1926 - 1937 | Coburg |
| Jim Shanahan | 1927 | Collingwood / Horsham / Camberwell |
| Maurie Johnson | 1927 - 1936 | Brunswick / Coburg Juniors |
| Vin Arthur | 1927 - 1933 | South Bendigo / Carlton / St Kilda / Richmond District / Drouin |
| Tommy Downs | 1927 - 1933 | Northcote |
| George Gough | 1927 - 1928 | Northcote / Fitzroy / Preston / Croxton IOR |
| Bill Downie | 1927 | Carlton District |
| Frank Mount | 1927 - 1928 | No Record of Original Club |
| Hector Ross | 1928 | Collingwood / Northcote |
| Billy Wood | 1928 | Northcote |
| Harry Davie | 1928 | Melbourne / Melbourne Juniors |
| Colin Martyn | 1928 - 1932 | Coburg |
| Bert Everett | 1928 - 1929 | Brunswick / Richmond Reserves |
| Jim Crowe | 1929 - 1934 | Railways * / Royal Rovers |
| Aubrey Martyn | 1929 - 1933 | Coburg |
| Jack Green | 1929 - 1933 | CBC Nth Melbourne (Uni. Amateurs) |
| Noel Peverill | 1929 | University Blacks / Scotch College (Hawthorn) |
| Ernie Sheil | 1929 - 1930 | University Blues |
| Tom Byrne | 1929 | Ararat / Williamstown / Fitzroy Reserves / Prahran VFA |
| Ansell Clarke | 1929 - 1937 | North Carlton Presbyterians |
| Fred Williams | 1929 - 1932 | Fitzroy / Melton |
| Les Allen | 1930 - 1931 | Fairfield |
| Bill Flynn | 1930 | Williamstown VFA / Fitzroy Reserves |
| Ted Pollock | 1930 - 1937 | Carlton Juniors / Queensland / Carlton Juniors |
| Bruce Scharp | 1930 - 1931 | Kew / University Blues / Scotch College (Hawthorn) |
| Len Clarke | 1931 | Coburg |
| Fred Brooks | 1931 | Teacher's Training College |
| Bernie O'Brien | 1931 | Footscray / Railways * |
| George Morrissey | 1931 | Kew / Port Melbourne / Nth Melbourne / Brunswick Juniors |
| Bill Jones | 1931 - 1932 | Port Melbourne / Dunlops * |
| Jack Kidd | 1931 | Tungamah / Essendon |
| Eric Little | 1931 - 1934 | Coburg |
| Gordon Mackie | 1932 - 1936 | Preston / Collingwood Reserves |
| Frank Walshe | 1932 | Footscray / Coburg / Trafalgar |
| Jack Hale | 1933 - 1941 | Carlton District / Abbotsford Juniors |
| Les Hughson | 1933 - 1934 | Preston / Fairfield / Hawthorn / Collingwood / Telegraphists (Wednesday League) |
| Steve Bloomer | 1933 | Nth Melbourne / Brunswick |
| Ray Quinn | 1933, 1935 | Carlton District |
| Harold Maskell | 1934 - 1935 | Collingwood Reserves / Geelong / Camperdown |
| Bobby Mills | 1934 | Footscray / Koo-wee-rup / Police |
| Jack Cashman | 1934 - 1935 | Fitzroy / West Perth / Fitzroy Juniors |
| Terry Ogden | 1934 | Hawthorn Reserves / Melbourne / Essendon Reserves / Northcote CYMS |
| Frank Anderson | 1934 - 1944 | Brunswick VFA |
| Wally Mutimer | 1934 - 1936 | Brunswick VFA |
| Dave Arrell | 1934 | Brunswick VFA |
| Bernie Treweek | 1934 - 1935 | Caulfield / CBC Victoria Parade |
| Norm Le Brun | 1935 | Collingwood / Essendon / Sandhurst / Sth Melb. / Richmond 2nd's / Moorabbin |
| Rod McLean | 1935 - 1946 | Fawkner |
| Clete Turner | 1935 | Fitzroy / Geelong / Cressy / Colac |
| Albert 'Mick' Price | 1936 - 1946 | Carlton Reserves |
| Will Kuhlken | 1936 - 1937 | Geelong / Port Melbourne |
| Jack Wrout | 1936 - 1944 | Nth Melbourne / West Melbourne CYMS |
| Frank P Williams | 1936 - 1937 | University Blacks / St Kevins College (Toorak) |
| Fred Ayers | 1937 - 1938 | Brunswick VFA |
| Paul Schmidt | 1937 - 1944 | Princes Hill |
| Arch Shields | 1937 - 1938 | Teacher's Training College * |
| Kevin Fox | 1937 - 1939 | Brunswick CYMS |
| Monty Brown | 1937 | University High School Old Boys (Parkville) |
| Jack McElroy | 1938 - 1939 | Brunswick VFA |
| Keith Rae | 1939, 1943 | Williamstown VFA / Carlton Juniors |
| Bernie Bignell | 1940, 1945 | Mantons * / Northcote High School |
| Jim Baird | 1941 - 1951 | Princes Hill |
| Vin Brown | 1941 - 1948 | Thornbury CYMS / Yea |
| Bob Atkinson | 1942 - 1944 | Coburg VFA / Camberwell South |
| Arthur Sleith | 1942 - 1943 | Preston VFA / Preston CYMS |
| Lance Collins | 1942 - 1945 | Coburg VFA |
| Fred Fitzgibbon | 1942 - 1948 | Brunswick VFA |
| Bob Standfield | 1942 | Brunswick VFA / Essendon / Collingwood Reserves / Leongatha / Fish Creek |
| Bert Deacon | 1942 - 1951 | Preston VFA |
| Ivor Brown | 1942 | Coburg VFA |
| Reg Morgan | 1942 - 1943 | Coburg VFA |
| Ken McLean | 1943 - 1946 | Coburg Sons of Soldiers |
| Ron Hines | 1943 - 1948 | Coburg District / RAAF * |
| Ron Boys | 1943 - 1947 | Northcote Reserves |
| Alex Way | 1944 - 1948 | Coburg Rangers |
| Jack Conley | 1944 - 1952 | Coburg Sons of Soldiers |
| Wal Alexander | 1945 - 1947 | Wodonga / Parkville Juniors /Footscray District |
| Adrian Hearn | 1945 | Fitzroy / North Melbourne CBC Old Boys |
| Ken Hopper | 1945 - 1946 | Pascoe Vale |
| Arthur Hall | 1945 | Fitzroy / Benalla All Blacks |
| Frank McGrath | 1945 | Melbourne / Boort |
| Ray Garby | 1946 - 1950 | Cohuna / Assumption College (Kilmore) / AIF * |
| Ritchie Green | 1946 - 1952 | East Brunswick |
| Len Harris | 1946 | Carlton District |
| Jim Clapton | 1946 | Northern District Association / Merri Juniors |
| Tom Eldridge | 1946 - 1947 | Carlton District / Brunswick 3rd's |
| Allan Greenshields | 1947 - 1949 | Rainbow / Pascoe Vale / Coburg VFA |
| Fred Stafford | 1947 - 1952 | Northcote VFA |
| Bob Kelsey | 1947 - 1948 | Port Melbourne VFA |
| Alan Streeter | 1948 - 1950 | North Fitzroy YCW |
| Tom Simmons | 1948 - 1949 | Northcote District |
| Basil Hunter | 1948 | Explosives Team (Saturday Morning Comp.) * |
| Tom Leehane | 1948 | CBC North Melbourne / East Brunswick YCW |
| Ken Aitken | 1948 - 1951 | East Coburg /Sth Merlynston / Coburg High School |
| Jack Hardy | 1949 | Newton NSW / Carlton / University Blacks / Essendon Reserves |
| Alan Thynne | 1949 - 1951 | Carlton District |
| Geoff Brokenshire | 1949 - 1950 | Collingwood / Sandringham VFA |
| Harry Caspar | 1950 - 1955 | Northcote VFA / Sorrento |
| Kevin Hart | 1950 | Fitzroy / Preston YCW |
| Doug Guy | 1950 - 1953 | East Brunswick |
| John Brown | 1950 - 1955 | New South Wales / Abbotsford Technical School |
| Bill Huntington | 1950 - 1951 | Coburg Juniors / Merlynston / Coburg High School |
| Harvey Dunn jnr | 1951 - 1954 | Box Hill / Essendon Stars / Essendon Technical School |
| Johnny Blake | 1951 | Northcote VFA |
| Bill Milroy | 1951 - 1956 | North Melbourne / Flinders Navy Base / Terang |
| George Stafford | 1951 - 1954 | Northcote VFA |
| Jack Spencer | 1952 - 1954 | Brunswick VFA |
| A. Max Thomas | 1952 - 1954 | Brunswick YCW |
| Graham Gilchrist | 1952 - 1961 | Coburg High School |
| Dick Gill | 1953 | Princes Hill |
| Ray Martini | 1953 | Essendon / Flemington YCW |
| Gerald Burke | 1953 - 1960 | Carlton Stars (Sunday League) |
| Peter Webster | 1953 - 1959 | Princes Hill |
| Peter Bevilacqua | 1953 | University Blues |
| Graham Kerr | 1954 - 1955 | University Blues |
| Frank Munro | 1954 - 1956 | Princes Hill Juniors |
| Kevin O'Brien | 1954 - 1957 | CBC Parade College (Bundoora) |
| Ron Rhodes | 1954 | Princes Hill |
| Jack Sullivan | 1955 - 1960 | St Joseph's CYMS (Nth Melb.) / North Coburg |
| Jack Ellis | 1955 - 1957 | Coburg High School |
| Kevin Bergin | 1955 - 1956 | Carlton District / Old Paradians (Bundoora) |
| Colin Holt | 1955 - 1957 | Brunswick |
| Leon Berner | 1955 - 1957 | University High School (Parkville) |
| Kevin Clarke | 1956 - 1959 | Melbourne / West Perth |
| Vic Garra | 1956 - 1959 | University High School (Parkville) |
| Kevan Hamilton | 1956 | Melbourne Reserves / McKinnon |
| Brian Buckley | 1956 - 1965 | Coburg U/17's |
| Maurie Pope | 1956 - 1958 | Carlton U/19's |
| Graham McColl | 1958 | Coburg VFA / Preston Swimmers |
| John Benetti | 1958 - 1965 | Carlton Stars / Old Paradians CBC College (Bundoora) |
| Serge Silvagni | 1958 - 1971 | West Preston YCW / CBC Parade College (Bundoora) / St Thomas, Clifton Hill |
| John Williams | 1959 - 1962 | Brunswick YCW / Princes Hill |
| Wes Lofts | 1960 - 1970 | West Coburg / Coburg Technical School |
| Max Miers | 1960 - 1961 | Princes Hill / Carlton Colts / Brunswick Technical School |
| Bruce McMaster-Smith | 1962 - 1964 | Fitzroy / Greensborough |
| Doug Ringholt | 1963 - 1964 | West Coburg |
| Kevin Hall | 1963 - 1973 | West Preston YCW |
| Dave Rogers | 1963 - 1964 | East Coburg |
| Brian Henderson | 1964 | Brunswick City |
| Ron Barassi | 1965 - 1969 | Melbourne / Preston Scouts |
| John Kemp | 1965 - 1966 | Pascoe Vale |
| Denis O'Sullivan | 1965 | Essendon U/19's / Batman / Coburg YCW |
| Barry Schmidt | 1965 | Carlton Youth Foundation / Collingwood Technical School |
| Stan Harrison | 1965 | West Preston YCW |
| Ricky McLean | 1966 - 1971 | Moonee Imperials |
| Paul Constance | 1966 | Carlton Youth Foundation |
| Peter Gilbert | 1966 | Broadmeadows |
| John Morrison | 1966 - 1967 | East Coburg / Princes Hill U/17's |
| Ron Auchettl | 1966 - 1969 | Merlynston |
| Robert Walls | 1967 - 1978 | Coburg Amateurs |
| Bruce Doull | 1969 - 1986 | Jacana |
| Phil Pinnell | 1969 - 1979 | Paramount |
| Doug Baird | 1969 - 1970 | Paramount |
| Barry Armstrong | 1969 - 1981 | Bundoora |
| John O'Connell | 1970 - 1976 | Glenroy YCW / St Mark's / Fawkner |
| Andy Lukas | 1970 - 1973 | St Mark's / Fawkner |
| Mark Amos | 1970 - 1971 | Montmorency / Robinvale |
| John Warden | 1971 - 1972 | St Mark's / Fawkner / Fawkner High School |
| Daryl Gutterson | 1971 | Lalor |
| David Dickson | 1972 - 1976 | Preston / Newlands High School / Powelltown |
| Rod Austin | 1972 - 1985 | Holy Child / St Dominic's |
| Vin Catoggio | 1973 - 1980 | Princes Hill |
| Alan Mangels | 1974 - 1980 | Oak Park / Northcote Park |
| Peter McKenna | 1977 | Collingwood / West Heidelberg YCW |
| Peter Bedford | 1977 - 1978 | South Melbourne / Port Melbourne |
| Wayne Harmes | 1977 - 1988 | Batman / Oak Park |
| Peter Halsall | 1978 | Pascoe Vale / Paramount |
| Alex Marcou | 1979 - 1986 | Thomastown |
| Stephen Buckley | 1980 | St Mark's / Fawkner |
| David Glascott | 1981 - 1991 | Thomastown |
| Rohan Burke | 1981 - 1986 | Reservoir-Lakeside |
| Spiro Kourkoumelis | 1981 - 1986 | Princes Hill |
| Rod Waddell | 1981 - 1982 | Lalor / Collingwood Reserves / Southern District NSW |
| Frank Marchesani | 1981 - 1985 | Fitzroy / Marcellin College (Bulleen) |
| Steve Easton | 1982 | North Melbourne / Bulleen-Templestowe |
| Paul Meldrum | 1982 - 1992 | Princes Hill |
| Mark Buckley | 1982 - 1985 | St Mark's / Fawkner |
| Justin Madden | 1983 - 1996 | Essendon / Airport West |
| Shane Robertson | 1983 - 1991 | North Melbourne Old Boys |
| Mark Williams | 1983 - 1988 | St Mark's / Fawkner |
| Andrew Graham | 1983 | Coburg |
| David Honybun | 1984 | Coleambally, NSW / Uni. Blues / Mackay, QLD / Uni. Blacks / Scotch College |
| Mick Kennedy | 1984 - 1989 | St Mark's / Fawkner |
| Darren Ogier | 1985 - 1987 | Hadfield |
| Neil Gaghan | 1985 | Fawkner / Moomba Park |
| Bernie Evans | 1986 - 1988 | Sydney Swans / Port Melbourne |
| Mil Hanna | 1986 - 1997 | East Brunswick |
| Ian Aitken | 1987 - 1992 | Strathmore |
| Jamie Dunlop | 1987 - 1990 | Fawkner / St Mark's |
| Mark Majerczak | 1987 - 1991 | Fawkner |
| Phil Poursanidis | 1988 - 1989 | Paramount |
| Tim Rieniets | 1990 - 1991 | Coburg VFA / North Melb. Reserves / Wangaratta Rovers |
| Adrian Bassett | 1990 - 1992 | Coburg VFA / Southport, QLD / Campbell's Creek / Castlemaine |
| Andrew Cavedon | 1991 - 1994 | Lalor Lions / Princes Hill |
| Darren Tarczon | 1991 - 1992 | North Melbourne Reserves / Port Melbourne |
| Ang Christou | 1991 - 2002 | Princes Hill / East Brunswick / Carlton Juniors / Carlton NSJFL |
| Mark Athorn | 1992 - 1993 | Sydney / Fitzroy / Footscray / Essendon U/19's / East Keilor |
| Ron De Iulio | 1992 - 1999 | Box Hill VFA / Brunswick VFA |
| Anthony Koutoufides | 1992 - 2007 | Lalor / East Thomastown |
| Brent Heaver | 1992 - 1996 | Epping / Melbourne / Epping |
| Lance Whitnall | 1997 - 2007 | Preston Knights U/18's / Lalor |
| Mark Porter | 1997 - 2001 | Coburg VFA / Wangaratta / King Valley |
| Anthony Franchina | 1997 - 2003 | Calder Cannons U/18's / Northern Knights U/18's / Newlands-Coburg |
| Trent Hoppner | 1998 | Preston Knights U/18's / Heidelberg |
| Andrew Merrington | 2000 - 2003 | St Bernards VAFA / Calder Cannons U/18's / Strathmore |
| Adam Pickering | 2001 - 2002 | Calder Cannons U/18s' / Cragieburn |
| Jim Plunkett | 2001 - 2003 | Western Bulldogs / Northern Knights U/18's / Montmorency |
| Andrew Eccles | 2002 - 2003 | Adelaide Crows / Northern Knights U/18's / St Mary's |
| Corey McKernan | 2002 - 2003 | North Melbourne / Westmeadows |
| Daniel Harford | 2004 | Hawthorn / Northern Knights U/18's / St Mary's |
| Nick Stevens | 2002 - 2003 | Port Power / Northern Knights U/18's / St Mary's |
| Jordan Bannister | 2004 - 2009 | Essendon / Calder Cannons U/18's / Therry-Penola |
| Jesse Smith | 2006 | Calder Cannons U/18's / Rupertswood |
| Ryan Jackson | 2006 - 2008 | Northern Knights U/18's / Greensborough |
| Ross Young | 2007 | Northern Bullants VFL / University Blues / Bendigo Pioneers U/18's / Donald |
| Matthew Kreuzer | 2008 - 2020 | Northern Knights U/18's / Bundoora |
| Dylan Buckley | 2012 - 2017 | Northern Knights U/18's /Ivanhoe Grammar / Ivanhoe |
| Jaryd Cachia | 2013 - 2014 | Norwood / Northern Knights U/18's / St Kevin's / Kew Rovers / Doutta Stars |
| Jack Newnes | 2020 - 2022 | St Kilda / Northern Knights U/18's / Ivanhoe |
| Sam Philp | 2020 - 2023 | Northern Knights U/18's / St Mary's |
| Adam Saad | 2021 - ? | West Coburg / Calder Cannons / Coburg (VFL) / Gold Coast Suns / Essendon |
Note: some football clubs have since disbanded or been renamed, and as a result the accuracy as to there actual geographical location is unknown. As Carlton is located in the Northern suburbs club, these clubs shall be allocated to this region, there will be an asterix (*) appearing after the name of these clubs indicating this. If you have knowledge as to the exact location of these clubs, please contact the Blueseum. These clubs of unknown origin will also be listed below in alphabetical order:
- AIF
- Army
- Austral
- Beverley
- British Star
- Brougham Street Methodists (possibly located in Nth Melbourne)
- Cardigan
- Celtic
- Clifton's Rope Works
- Criterion Juniors
- Cumberland
- Dunlop's
- Explosives Team (Saturday Morning Comp.)
- Fire Brigade
- Mantons
- Marylebone
- Montague Juniors (possibly located in South Melbourne)
- Napier Imperials (possibly located South Melbourne)
- North Park
- Phoenix
- Police
- RAAF
- Railways
- Stanley United
- St Ignatius (possibly located in Richmond)
- St Luke's
- Teacher's Training College (possible located in Carlton / Parkville)
- Telegraphists (Wednesday League)
- Tramways